The following players have worn jersey number 39 in a VFL/AFL premiership match.
Most games: 158 - Neville Jetta
Most goals: 41 - Gerard Healy
| Player | Years | Notes |
| Bill Latham | 1928 | #36 in 1927 |
| Lew Gough | 1930 | #31 in 1931 |
| Frank Kennedy | 1944 | #37 in 1945, #17 from 1946-1947 |
| Jack Stock | 1944 | #38 in 1945 |
| Maurie Reeves | 1953 | |
| Tom Magee | 1954 | |
| Bill Byrne | 1957 | |
| Peter Brenchley | 1958 | #38 from 1957-1959 |
| Herbie Matthews | 1961-1964 | |
| Rick Feldmann | 1966-1967 | #40 in 1965 |
| George Lakes | 1968 | #9 from 1969 to 1972 |
| Russell Colcott | 1969-1971 | |
| Peter Dilnot | 1972-1973 | |
| Kevin Moore | 1974 | |
| Mark Alves | 1977 | |
| Gerard Healy | 1979-1981 | #3 from 1982-1985 |
| Trevor Castles | 1983 | |
| Jeremy Nichols | 1986 | |
| Doug Koop | 1987-1988 | |
| Stuart Cameron | 1990 | |
| Craig Smoker | 1998-1999 | |
| Austin Wonaeamirri | 2008 | #33 from 2010-2011 |
| Neville Jetta | 2009-2021 | #50 in Round 10, 2017 |
Players who didn't play a senior match.
| Player | Years | Notes |
| Cowell | 1914 | |
| Harry New | 1943 | Number 20 in 1944 and 1945 |
| Ken Kick | 1955 | |
| Murray Gainger | 1959 | |
| John Eastgate | 1960 | |
| Brian Gilchrist | 1961 | |
| Gary Wynd | 1965 | Number 40 in 1966 |
| David Morrison | 1991 | |
| Robert Lemon | 1992 | |
| Jeff Hilton | 1993 | |
| Dean Brown | 1994 | |
| Michael Polley | 1995 | Number 14 in 1996 |
| Ashley Gehling | 1996 | |
| Brent Williams | 1998 | |
| Michael Clark | 2000 | |
| Mitchell Craig | 2001 | |
| Ezra Poyas | 2003-2004 | |
| Shane Neaves | 2006-2007 |