| VFL/AFL | AFLW | |
VFL/AFL
Most games: 178 - Hassa Mann
Most goals: 193 - Hassa Mann
| Player | Years | Notes |
| Jack Evans | 1912 | #8 in 1913, 1915, #7 in 1914, #28 in 1919 |
| Herb Joolen | 1912-1913 | |
| Charlie Armstrong | 1914, 1919 | #21 in 1913 |
| Alf George | 1915 | #3 in 1912, #14 in 1913 |
| Frank Cummins | 1919 | |
| George Garlick | 1920 | |
| Les Wallace | 1921 | |
| Hugh Dunbar | 1922 | #28 in 1923-1928 |
| Jack Robertson | 1923 | |
| Jimmy Davidson | 1925-1932 | |
| Reg Conole | 1933 | #22 from 1930 to 1932 |
| Jack Young | 1934 | |
| Jock Ball | 1935-1937 | |
| Harden Dean | 1938 | #11 in 1936, #38 in 1943 |
| Jack O'Keefe | 1939-1942 | |
| Colin Bradley | 1942 | #15 from 1943 to 1944 |
| Jack Minnis | 1943 | #32 in 1944 |
| Ken Levey | 1944 | #31 in 1943 |
| Alf Copsey | 1946 | |
| Harry Rowe | 1946 | |
| Ray Jones | 1949 | |
| Ken McKaige | 1951-1952 | |
| Tony Bull | 1953-1957 | |
| Brian Dunsford | 1957 | |
| Hassa Mann | 1959-1968 | |
| Steve Arnott | 1969 | |
| Noel Leary | 1970-1973 | |
| David Murray | 1974 | |
| Terry Wilkins | 1976 | #38 in 1975 |
| Andrew Moir | 1977-1981 | |
| Dale Dickson | 1982-1986 | |
| Peter Kiel | 1987 | |
| Dean Chiron | 1987-1989 | |
| Andrew Obst | 1990-1994 | #4 from 1995 to 1997 |
| Shaun Smith | 1995-1998 | |
| Chris Lamb | 1999-2004 | |
| Michael Newton | 2007-2011 | |
| Jayden Hunt | 2016-2022 | |
| Joel Smith | 2023)) | #44 from 2017 to 2022 |
No senior games
| Player | Years | Notes |
| Ron Perkins | 1947 | |
| Jock Farquharson | 1948 | |
| Tom Campbell | 2025- | |
AFLW
Most games: Eden Zanker - 64
Most goals: Eden Zanker - 49
| Player | Years | Notes |
| Eden Zanker | 2018 - |