| VFL/AFL | AFLW | ||
VFL/AFL
Most games: 160 - Travis Johnstone
Most goals: 242 - Robert C Johnson
| Player | Years | Notes | |
| Bill Flintoft | 1912 | ||
| Bill Angwin | 1913 | ||
| Bobby Monk | 1914 | #9 in 1912, #5 in 1913 | |
| Roy Park | 1915 | ||
| George Walker | 1919 | #26 in 1914, #20 in 1915 and 1920-1921, #28 in 1920 | |
| Hughie Odgers | 1920 | #26 in 1912 | |
| Clarrie Lethlean | 1921 | ||
| Derek Mollison | 1923-1925 | #11 from 1925 to 1928 | |
| Robert C Johnson | 1926-1932 | #11 in 1933 | |
| Eric Glass | 1933-1938 | ||
| Gerry Daly | 1939 | #27 from 1940-1941 and 1946 | |
| Jack Atkins | 1940 | ||
| Hughie McPherson | 1941 and 1943-1944 | #25 in 1942 | |
| Tom Ferguson | 1942 | #22 in 1943 | |
| George Bickford | 1945-1952 | ||
| Clyde Laidlaw | 1954-1956 | #35 from 1957 to 1962 | |
| Robert B Johnson | 1957-1961 | #18 from 1954 to 1956 | |
| John Townsend | 1962-72 | ||
| Peter Keays | 1975-1977 | #42 in 1974 | |
| Robert Walters | 1979-1981 | #32 from 1977 to 1978 | |
| Adrian Battiston | 1982-1987 | ||
| Andy Lovell | 1988-1995 | ||
| David Grant | 1996 | ||
| Robert Pyman | 1997 | ||
| Travis Johnstone | 1998-2007 | ||
| Jack Grimes | 2008-2012 | ||
| Dean Kent | 2014-2018 | #34 in 2013 | |
| Kade Kolodjashnij | 2019-2020 | ||
| Bailey Laurie | 2023- | Also wore number in 2022 without playing a game | |
No senior games
| Player | Years | Notes | |
| Harden Dean | 1941 | #11 in 1936, #29 in 1938, #38 in 1943 | |
| J. Callinan | 1942 | ||
| Jack Green | 1945 | ||
| Ray Hutchins | 1953 | #24 in 1950-51 | |
| Graham Mills | 1973 | ||
| Michael Giulieri | 1978 | #54 in 1976 | |
AFLW
Most games: 48 - Alyssa Bannan
Most goals: 41 - Alyssa Bannan
| Player | Years | Notes | |
| Aliesha Newman | 2017 - 2020 | ||
| Alyssa Bannan | 2021 - 2023 | Number 6 from 2024 AFLW season | |
| Grace Beasley | 2024- | ||