For 1859-1939 see Unknown players Pre-VFL and Unknown Players 1890s-1920s
1950s
| Name | Year | Notes | ||
| Adams | 1953 | Thirds | ||
| B. Andersen | 1956 | Cleared to Box Hill before 1957 | ||
| Anderson | 1952 | Thirds | ||
| Antoni | 1950 | Seconds defender | ||
| Apted | 1956 | Reserve in the 1956 Exhibition Game vs North West Football Union | ||
| N. Baker | 1952 | Pre-season forward from Heathcote. Probably Noel Baker. | ||
| Baker | 1958 | Thirds | ||
| Beer | 1955 | Thirds | ||
| Bell | 1956-58 | Thirds. Seconds in 1958 | ||
| Biggs | 1956 | Seconds emergency | ||
| Blake | 1951 | Seconds emergency | ||
| Bodinnar | 1952 | Thirds | ||
| Bosch | 1959 | Seconds | ||
| Box | 1957 | Thirds | ||
| Brain | 1958 | Thirds | ||
| Brown | 1950 | Seconds. Possibly Ken Brown | ||
| Browne | 1956 | Thirds | ||
| H. Burrows | 1957 | From Murrumbeena | ||
| J. Caboon | 1952 | Pre-season half forward from Heathcote | ||
| R. Carlson | 1950 | Toured Tasmania. Photo at http://trove.nla.gov.au/ndp/del/article/52781328 | ||
| Carlin | 1950 | Seconds player. Possibly the same as R. Carlson. | ||
| Carson | 1958 | Thirds | ||
| Carteris | 1954 | Pre-season centre from Yarrawonga | ||
| Chandler | 1951 | Thirds | ||
| W. Clark | 1955 | Seconds | ||
| M. Close | 1955-56 | Thirds. From Murrumbeena Juniors. To Dandenong in 1958. VFA Project profile | ||
| Collins | 1956 | Thirds | ||
| GP Conroy | 1955-56 | Thirds. From Armadale CYMS | ||
| Cooke | 1951 | Thirds | ||
| Cotter | 1954-55 | Thirds. Probably the N. Cotter cleared to Camberwell in 1959 | ||
| Crozier | 1958 | Thirds | ||
| Crutchfield | 1958 | Thirds | ||
| P. Cumming | 1955-56 | Thirds. From Gardenvale CYMS | ||
| G. Cutler | 1953-1954 | Thirds player who was cleared to the senior side in the 1954 pre-season. | ||
| AW Daley | 1952 | To Moorabbin June 1952 | ||
| Davis | 1956 | Thirds | ||
| Daymond | 1954 | Thirds | ||
| N. Dickson | 1952 | From Red Cliffs. Shown as "to be considered when available" due to military training. May have been Royce Dickson. | ||
| D. Donaldson | 1952 | Pre-season player from Colac. | ||
| J. Elliott | 1952 | Supplementary list player | ||
| Escreet | 1965 | Reserves | ||
| R. Evans | 1955-59 | Thirds in 1958. From MHSOB. Wore #42 in 1959 when promoted to supplementary list. The 1958/59 one is not Dick Evans | ||
| J. Fasso | 1952 | Pre-season ruckman from Heathcote | ||
| Fitzgerald | 1951-52 | Thirds | ||
| K. Fitzgerald | 1956 | From North Melbourne thirds | ||
| Foard | 1956 | Thirds | ||
| Garrett | 1952 | Thirds | ||
| Gasparini | 1951 | Seconds | ||
| Gatford | 1953 | Thirds | ||
| P. Gayne | 1956 | Cleared from Moe in April | ||
| Germaine | 1951-1952 | Seconds. Possibly Lou Germaine | ||
| Gill | 1950 | Seconds. Possibly Barry Gill or the 1948 Gill. | ||
| Gill | 1954 | Thirds. Possibly Barry Gill | ||
| Max Ga???rold | 1954 | 20-year-old full back from Eltham. Full name obscured. | ||
| Goodluck | 1952 | Thirds | ||
| Grant | 1956-57 | Thirds. Possibly Lee Grant | ||
| Grierson | 1954-1955 | 1954 pre-season player from South Bendigo. Probably A. Grierson | ||
| MG Grunden | 1958 | From Millgrove | ||
| Halfpenny | 1958 | Thirds | ||
| G. Harris | 1957-59 | Fourths/Thirds/Seconds | ||
| Hart | 1950 | Seconds emergency | ||
| Haycroft | 1954-55 | Thirds | ||
| M. Hawes | 1954 | Wore #15. Probably Bill Hawes | ||
| Heath | 1955 | Thirds | ||
| SN Hollow | 1950-1951 | Seconds. From St Kilda | ||
| Iles | 1950 | Seconds emergency | ||
| Jeffrey | 1958 | Thirds. Probably B. Jeffrey from 1960. | ||
| Jennings | 1958 | Thirds | ||
| Johnson | 1950-51 | Thirds captain 1953 and 1954. Possibly Neville Johnson. | ||
| Jones | 1952-55 | Thirds captain in 1955 | ||
| W. Jones | 1953 | From Seconds to Prahran in 1954 pre-season | ||
| B. Joyner | 1959 | From Ferntree Gully | ||
| R. Kellett | 1955 | Probably Hayden Kellett | ||
| Kennedy | 1950 | From Bairnsdale. Also shown as Kallady | ||
| AE Kruse | 1951 | From Black Rock | ||
| K. Larkin | 1959 | From Bentleigh | ||
| Lason | 1951 | Seconds | ||
| Lewis | 1957 | Thirds | ||
| D. Longey | 1955 | Possibly a misspelling of G. Longney | ||
| Madden | 1951 | Seconds emergency | ||
| T. Magee | 1956? | Shown as being cleared to Yarraville in 1957. Possibly Tom Magee, but he had already gone from MFC to Caulfield in 1955. | ||
| H. Marks | 1953 | From Prahran in June | ||
| Martin | 1951 | Seconds | ||
| Martin | 1958 | Thirds | ||
| D. McConachy | 1953 | From South Melbourne. Probably same as McConaghy. | ||
| McConaghy | 1953-58 | Thirds in 53/54, Seconds in 58 | ||
| NW McDonell | 1950 | From Camberwell to the Seconds | ||
| J McDonald | 1951 | From Camberwell. Possibly the same as NW McDonell. | ||
| McDonald | 1953 | Thirds. Probably Ian McDonald | ||
| McDonald | 1958 | Thirds | ||
| E. McGowan | 1955 | Thirds From Hamilton. Also shown as from Murrumbeena. Probably Ed McGowan. | ||
| McGowan | 1956 | Seconds emergency. Probably the same as E. McGowan 1955. | ||
| McLean | 1950 | Seconds. Possibly Alan McLean | ||
| McNamara | 1950 | Seconds | ||
| Meuleman | 1957 | Thirds | ||
| A. Mollison | 1950 | From Surrey Hills. Seconds emergency | ||
| Morgan | 1956-57 | Thirds | ||
| Morton | 1958 | Thirds. Possibly Ken Morton | ||
| Moule | 1956-57 | Reserves and Thirds | ||
| Nash | 1956 | Seconds emergency | ||
| R. Neville | 1958 | From Prahran Thirds | ||
| O'Brien | 1954 | Thirds | ||
| O'Hare/O'Heare | 1950 | Seconds ruckman | ||
| O'Keefe | 1950-1951 | Seconds. Probably the same as the 1948-49 O'Keefe | ||
| G. O'Keefe | 1952 | Listed as "to be considered when available" due to illness. Possibly the same as the 1948-49 and/or 1950-1951 O'Keefe | ||
| D. Parkinson | 1958 | From Footscray Seconds | ||
| Parris | 1950 | Seconds | ||
| Pearson | 1954-1955 | Thirds | ||
| Pevitt | 1950 | Seconds wingman | ||
| PT Phelan | 1955-56 | Thirds. From Bentleigh CYMS | ||
| Pollard | 1952 | Thirdss | ||
| Power | 1951 | Thirds. Probably John Power | ||
| Rankin | 1958 | Seconds | ||
| TD Rankin | 1959 | Promoted from the Fourths. Possibly the same as the 1958 Rankin. | ||
| Raynor | 1957 | Thirds | ||
| J. Reid | 1954 | Pre-season player from Glenhuntly | ||
| Reynolds | 1958 | Thirds | ||
| Robinson | 1956-57 | Thirds | ||
| R. Robinson | 1951 | Dropped from the list in April 1952. Possibly Ross Robertson. | ||
| R. Robertson | 1951 | Seconds. Listed in the same side as Ross Robertson.. | ||
| M. Russell | 1951 | From St Kilda/Old Scotch. Probably Manson Russell, born 26/12/1929 | ||
| Ryan | 1951 | Thirds | ||
| Sadler | 1950 | Seconds | ||
| Scott | 1956 | Seconds emergency | ||
| L. Scotland | 1957 | Fourths | ||
| L. Seawood | 1956-57 | 1956 Fourths, 1957 Thirds | ||
| Sharkey | 1955 | Thirds | ||
| NJ Sheahan | 1959 | From Devonport | ||
| Short | 1950 | Seconds defender | ||
| Smith | 1950 | Thirds | ||
| Smythe | 1950 | Seconds player | ||
| Steel | 1958 | Thirds | ||
| Stewart | 1950 | Pre-season recruit rover from Western District. | ||
| R. Stoniel | 1950 | To Box Hill in May 1951 | ||
| Strickland | 1955 | Seconds player | ||
| P. Strownix | 1954 | From Croydon Juniors | ||
| Tarriff | 1950 | Seconds defender | ||
| Taylor | 1953 | Pre-season wing recruit | ||
| Taylor | 1956 | |||
| Thorne | 1955-56 | Thirds | ||
| Tonge | 1951 | Thirds | ||
| Tonkin | 1951-52 | Thirds | ||
| B. Tonzing | 1959 | From Merbein | ||
| Webster | 1951-54 | Thirds. Probably Fred Webster | ||
| Wellington | 1958 | Thirds | ||
| PW Westmore | 1955, 1957 | Unattached in 1955. From South Bendigo in 1957. | ||
| Wheatley | 1950 | Seconds | ||
| Whitehead | 1951 | Thirds. Possibly Bill Whitehead. | ||
| Wildie | 1956-57 | Thirds | ||
| Willarton | 1950 | Seconds emergency | ||
| Williams | 1958 | Thirds | ||
| Wills | 1951 | Thirds | ||
| B. Wilson | 1953 | Thirds. From Ormond | ||
| Woods | 1950 | Seconds emergency | ||
| G. Wood/Woods | 1953 | Pre-season follower from Wangaratta | ||
| Young | 1958 | Thirds | ||
1960s
| Name | Year | Notes | ||
| L. Allen/Allan | 1969 | |||
| C. Anderson | 1969 | Wore #36 | ||
| D. Anderson | 1969-1971 | Fourths in 1969 | ||
| R. Anderson | 1969 | Fourths | ||
| R. Andrews | 1969 | Under 19s | ||
| K. Baker | 1960 | From Heathmont | ||
| R. Ball | 1960 | From no previous club | ||
| R. Beaton | 1964 | Reserves player. Wore #49 | ||
| Birch | 1965 | Pre-season player | ||
| Bird | 1969 | Possibly Wayne Bird | ||
| Bisson | 1968 | |||
| Bosch | 1960 | Reserves | ||
| G. Bourke | 1964 | Wore #49 | ||
| G. Breen | 1960 | Reserves. Wore #43 | ||
| M.Brodie | 1962-64 | 1962 Fourths B&F and 1963-64 Under 19's | ||
| Brown | 1969 | |||
| Caplin | 1966 | Reserves. Possibly Sid Catlin. | ||
| Carbury | 1966 | Pre-season player. | ||
| Carlson | 1964 | Reserves (Age 31/07/1964) | ||
| Carlson | 1969 | |||
| Caulfield | 1969 | |||
| K. Clapham | 1960 | From Stanhope | ||
| A. Cooke | 1966 | To Williamstown in 1967 | ||
| N. Corrigan | 1960-62 | Under 19s. Second B&F in 1962 | ||
| D. Cranage | 1968 | Wore #56 | ||
| Croughan | 1969 | |||
| Curry | 1966 | Reserves | ||
| N. Curry | 1969 | Under 19s | ||
| K. D'Arch | 1964 | Fourths. Possibly same as K. Darcy. | ||
| C. Daly | 1962 | Wore #50 | ||
| K. Darcy | 1964 | Under 19s. Premiership player. | ||
| T. Date | 1962 | Joint Fourths B&F winner | ||
| B. Deas | 1969 | Under 19s | ||
| P. Dinon/Dynon | 1960 | From East St Kilda YCW | ||
| K. Dixon | 1961 | From Moorabbin | ||
| R. Edmunds | 1964 | Wore #51. To Preston in 1966. | ||
| G. Edwards | 1960 | Reserves From McKinnon Thirds | ||
| Ekland | 1966 | Pre-season player | ||
| P. Elliott | 1969 | Under 19s. Also wore #47 in Reserves. | ||
| G. Emselle | 1968 | Under 19s | ||
| P. Etheredge | 1968-70 | Fourths in 1969. Number 47 in 1970. | ||
| Fanning | 1966 | Pre-season | ||
| E. Feldmen | 1965 | Fourths | ||
| Fletcher | 1969 | Played in a Sydney exhibition game | ||
| G. Fraser | 1961 | Under 19s. Second Best and Fairest | ||
| G. Fraser | 1966 | Fourths | ||
| R. Girdwood | 1967 | Fourths | ||
| Glazner | 1969 | Probably Neil Glazner at Caulfield | 1971-1975 | Probably the same Caulfield as 1969 |
| D.Gough | 1968 | Under 19s. Possibly B. Gough. | ||
| R. Grant | 1969 | Fourths | ||
| R. Groves | 1960-61 | Under 19's. From McKinnon | ||
| Hancy | 1960 | From Hampton High School | ||
| Harrigan | 1965 | Pre-season player | ||
| C. Harrison | 1963 | Under 19's. VFL representative against South Australia | ||
| G. Heard | 1960 | From Diamond Creek. Reserves. Wore #49 | ||
| NF. Hicks | 1960 | From Mentone Wore #51 | ||
| G. Hill | 1969-1970 | Under 19s 1969, Number 52 in 1970 | ||
| Hollings | 1967-69 | 1967 Fourths B&F. 1969 Under 19s/Reserves | ||
| I. Hunter | 1961 | From McKinnon | ||
| Hurridan | 1966 | Pre-season player | ||
| Innerson | 1961 | Reserves. Not Malcolm Inness | ||
| P. Jackson | 1968 | Wore #55 | ||
| B. Jeffrey | 1960 | Wore #48. Probably Jeffrey from 1958. | ||
| Jeffries | 1960 | Probably B. Jeffrey | ||
| A. Jenkin | 1968-1969 | Under 19s | ||
| Jennings | 1967 | |||
| B. Jukes | 1960 | From McKinnon | ||
| R. Keane | 1961 | Fourths | ||
| D. King | 1965 | Fourths | ||
| P. Kingston | 1966 | Under 19s | ||
| C. Kinnear | 1964 | Fourths | ||
| H. Knape | 1967 | Shown as joining Prahran in early 1968. Possibly Alan Knape | ||
| J. Lade | 1967 | Wore #42 in 1967. Possibly same as Roger Lade. Retired before the 1968 season. | ||
| Langford | 1966 | Pre-season player | ||
| D. Leahy | 1965 | Fourths | ||
| S. Leahy | 1961 | Reserves. Probably a mispelling of T or B Leahy | ||
| G. Leatham | 1961 | From Sale | ||
| G. Leslie | 1969 | Fourths | ||
| J. Little | 1964 | Fourths/Under 19's. Under 19s premiership player | ||
| O'Mahony | 1963 | Seconds player (Age 02/08/1963) | ||
| A. Marr | 1964 | Under 19s | ||
| J. Marks | 1969 | Under 19s | ||
| A. Mars | 1965 | Fourths and Under 19's (Second B&F in U19) | ||
| I. Marshall | 1969 | Fourths | ||
| B. Martin | 1969-1971 | Cleared to Prahran in 1972. Wore #53 in 1970 and 1971 | ||
| R. Maygar | 1967 | Under 19s | ||
| R. McDonald | 1969-70 | Wore #51 in 1970 | ||
| McInerney | 1965 | Pre-season player | ||
| McInnes | 1969 | |||
| E. McLean | 1960 | From McKinnon | ||
| R. McLean | 1969 | Under 19s. Possibly the same as McLean 1972-73 | ||
| R. Mervicich | 1966-69 | 1966 Fourths player, 1968 Under 19s and Reserves player. 1969 Under 19s | ||
| N. Millard | 1963 | Wore #48. May have been related to 1964's John Millard | ||
| J. Miller | 1961 | Fourths | ||
| I. Milne | 1963 | Fourths | ||
| Missen | 1969 | |||
| B. Mitchell | 1969-71 | Fourths and Under 19's in 1969 | ||
| R. Mitchell | 1964 | Wore #50 | ||
| A. Moller | 1966 | Wore #54. Reserves | ||
| G. Molloy | 1969 | Fourths | ||
| G. Mortimer | 1960 | From Tocumwal. Played three games for Waverley (from Glen Waverley) in 192 | ||
| T. Moylan | 1969-70 | From Dookie. Wore #42 in 1969 (Age 30/03/1970). | ||
| J. Murdock | 1960 | From McKinnon | ||
| M. Nash | 1965 | Fourths | ||
| D. Nish | 1968 | Fourths | ||
| J. North | 1968 | Wore #47 | ||
| C. O'Farrell | 1969 | Under 19s | ||
| Patterson | 1966 | Pre-season player | ||
| Paul | 1961 | Reserves player | ||
| D. Pearson | 1959-60 | From the Fourths in 1960 | ||
| I. Predl | 1960 | Under 19's. From Valley United | ||
| N. Prideaux | 1960 | From Broken Hill | ||
| R. Pritchard | 1964-1965 | Under 19s premiership player/pre-season player | ||
| W. Rice | 1969 | Under 19s | ||
| Richardson | 1966 | Pre-season player | ||
| Roache | 1966 | Pre-season player | ||
| Roberts | 1969 | |||
| T. Roberts | 1968 | Fourths | ||
| R. Rowarth | 1964 | Under 19s premiership player | ||
| Russell | 1960-1961 | 1960 Under 19s, 1961 Reserves (likely also Under 19s) (Age 02/06/1961) | ||
| R. Sampson | 1969 | Under 19s | Possibly Ray Sampson | |
| I. Saunders | 1969 | Under 19s. Possibly the same as Cyril Saunders | ||
| G. Sherwood | 1960 | From McKinnon | ||
| Simmons | 1960 | |||
| F. Smith | 1963 | Under 19s | ||
| J. Snell | 1964 | Wore #45 | ||
| Stephenson | 1969-71 | Possibly the I. Stephenson who played for Dandenong in 1974 | ||
| P. Stewart | 1960 | From Murrumbeena | ||
| R. Stone | 1965-67 | Fourths in 1965. Wore #49 in 1967. | ||
| JW Taylor | 1959-60 | Fourths in 1959, cleared to the club proper in 1960. | ||
| K. Taylor | 1969-1971 | Fourths | ||
| R. Taylor | 1969-72 | Fourths in 1969. Under 19's Deputy Vice Captain in 1971 and also played Reserves. Wore #44 in 1972 then retired | ||
| Tepper | 1969 | |||
| J. Totton | 1961 | Promoted from Fourths | ||
| R. Treloar | 1960-61 | Reserves in 1961. From Boronia (Age 05/05/1960) | ||
| P. Walker | 1969 | Under 19s. Likely the same person as T. Walker. Reported for striking in the R3, 1969 U19s game. | ||
| T. Walker | 1969 | Fourths and Under 19s | ||
| A. Warburton | 1969 | Fourths | ||
| L. Warburton | 1969 | Under 19s | ||
| D. Watson | 1967 | Wore #40 in 1967 | ||
| K. Wecker | 1969 | Fourths | ||
| Weir | 1969 | |||
| G. Welsh | 1969 | Fourths | ||
| White | 1964 | Under 19s. Emergency in Grand Final | ||
| K Williams | 1966 | Fourths | ||
| K Wilson | 1969 | Fourths. Possibly the same as KA Wilson from 1975 | ||
| R. Winch | 1969 | Fourths | ||
| M. Witomski | 1963-64 | Wore #52 in 1963 and #44 in 1964 | ||
| G. Woods | 1969-1971 | Fourths in 1969 | ||
1970s
| Name | Year | Notes | ||
| Baber | 1974 | Reserves. Probably the same as A. Baker. | ||
| Batty | 1977 | |||
| G. Bell | 1971 | |||
| R. Beverley | 1971 | Fourths | ||
| C. Bradley | 1971 | |||
| Bull | 1979 | |||
| Burns | 1977 | Possibly Richard Burn | ||
| P. Chapman | 1974 | To Oakleigh in 1975 | ||
| Clarke | 1976 | Reserves. Possibly Geoff Clarke | ||
| Clark | 1977 | Reserves. Shown in same team as Geoff Clarke | ||
| Coghlan | 1974 | Reserves player. Also shown as Goghlan. | ||
| J. Conley | 1971 | Probably Peter Conley | ||
| D. Convey | 1976 | Under 19s | ||
| CN Crompton | 1975 | From South Melbourne | ||
| Cumming | 1979 | |||
| P. Cunningham | 1978-1979 | Possibly the R. Cunningham delisted in April 1979 | ||
| D'Ambrosia | 1978 | |||
| M. DeKing | 1971 | Fourths | ||
| Denko | 1979-1980 | Reserves | ||
| Dickinson | 1979-1980 | Possibly Russell Dickson or Ross Dickson | ||
| Drysdale | 1978 | Reserves | ||
| Fawcus | 1971 | Fourths | ||
| P. Fides | 1971 | Fourths | ||
| T. Gerard | 1975 | To Caulfield | ||
| G. Giles | 1974 | Under 19s. Probably Glenn Giles | ||
| Glenn | 1974 | Reserves player | ||
| Grantley | 1974 | Reserves player | ||
| M. Hamblin | 1971 | |||
| Harvey | 1977 | Reserves | ||
| A. Henderson | 1971 | |||
| Henke | 1977 | |||
| Hewitt | 1979 | |||
| Horne | 1976 | Reserves player | ||
| Hughes | 1974 | To Caulfield in 1975 | ||
| Jarrett | 1977 | Reserves | ||
| H. Jeffrey | 1971 | |||
| J. Johnson | 1979 | |||
| Jones | 1976-77 | Possibly Barry Jones or Stuart Jones | ||
| Lattrey | 1974 | Reserves | ||
| G. Lee | 1971 | Fourths | ||
| Mackay | 1975 | Under 19s | ||
| Manson | 1974 | Reserves player. Probably not Peter Manson | ||
| R. Mather | 1975 | From Footscray, to Yarraville. Possibly Ron Mather | ||
| J. McCaughan | 1971 | |||
| C. McDonough | 1971 | Fourths | ||
| P. McGivern | 1978 | Under 19s | ||
| A. McGuinness | 1972-75 | To Keysborough at the end of the year | ||
| McKenna | 1973 | Possibly M. McKenna from 1975 | ||
| M. McKenna | 1975 | To Macedon at the end of the year. Possibly McKenna from 1973 | ||
| McLean | 1972-73 | Under 19s in 1972. Possibly the same as McLean 1975. | ||
| McLean | 1974 | Reserves player | ||
| W. McLean | 1975 | To Lang Lang at the end of the year | ||
| McMillan | 1973 | Possibly Neil McMullin misspelled | ||
| Mills | 1975 | Reserves. Probably either Graham Mills or Neville Mills | ||
| C. McQueen | 1978 | Left in April 1979 | ||
| Moore | 1974 | Reserves player. Possibly Geoffrey Moore | ||
| D. Newlan | 1974 | To Sandringham in 1975 | ||
| O'Brien | 1979 | Probably Mark O'Brien | ||
| O'Connell | 1973 | |||
| D. O'Sullivan | 1973 | |||
| Osmond | 1974 | Reserves. Possibly Geoff Osmand | ||
| C. Parkhill | 1971 | |||
| Patten | 1974 | Reserves player. Name may have been a typo. | ||
| W. Perrett | 1971-72 | Under 19's . Possibly Ross Perrett | ||
| Pickford | 1978-79 | |||
| Rae | 1977 | Probably Mick Rea | ||
| Richards | 1977 | |||
| N. Richardson | 1971 | Fourths | ||
| I. Salmon | 1977 | |||
| C. Scott | 1974 | Reserves. Possibly Graham Scott misspelt. | ||
| K. Scott | 1971 | Fourths | ||
| B. Sherwood | 1974 | To Lang Lang in 1975 | ||
| B. Shields | 1973 | Wore #38 in 1973 | ||
| Signoretti | 1974 | Reserves player | ||
| Simmons | 1973 | |||
| M. Smith | 1975 | To Prahran. Probably the Smith in 1974 Reserves teams. | ||
| R. Stomann | 1974 | To Prahran in 1975 | ||
| Stromjlani | 1979 | |||
| Swan | 1974 | Reserves player | ||
| T. Tarrent | 1974 | To Dandenong in 1975 | ||
| C. Thompson | 1977 | Dropped from list in 1978 pre-season | ||
| Todd | 1978 | |||
| Vanderheyden | 1979 | |||
| Vockenna | 1974 | Reserves player. Likely a mispelling of another name. | ||
| P. Williams | 1975 | [https://news.google.com.au/newspapers?id=DPJUAAAAIBAJ&sjid=OpIDAAAAIBAJ&pg=5221%2C6582596 | On senior list] | |
| A. Wilson | 1974 | To Bentleigh Meth in 1975 | ||
| KA Wilson | 1975 | To Sandringham. Possibly known as Andrew Wilson. Possibly the same K. Wilson as 1969 | ||
| G. Woods | 1972 | Cleared to Sandringham in 1972 | ||
| Wright | 1976 | Under 19's | ||
1980s
| Name | Year | Notes | ||
| Bateman | 1983 | Possibly the Brendon Bateman who was a scholarship player in 1979 | ||
| Best | 1988 | Reserves. Possibly a misinterpretation of 'best' players. | ||
| Bright | 1983 | |||
| D. Bourne | 1984 | Under 19s | ||
| R. Chapman | 1982 | Norm Smith Squad in 1982 | ||
| Cole | 1985 | |||
| Corrigan | 1980 | |||
| Conger | 1984 | |||
| Crowe | 1980 | |||
| Dimmatina | 1980 | Maybe have been the Dimmatina in South Melbourne Reserves 1979 (Age 10/08/1979) | ||
| R. Dixon | 1981 | Reserves | ||
| Ford | 1980 | Probably Chris Ford | ||
| N. Hopkins | 1982 | Norm Smith Squad in 1982 | ||
| Howard | 1989 | Possibly a misspelling of John Howat | ||
| MacDermod | 1981 | Reserves | ||
| McKenzie | 1980 | Possibly Stuart McKenzie | ||
| O'Dwyer | 1980 | Round 13 Reserves emergency | ||
| P. Osiurak | 1980-1981 | Under 19s/Reserves. Probably Peter. | ||
| S. Pappon | 1982 | Norm Smith Squad in 1982. First name likely Steve. | ||
| N. Robertson | 1980 | |||
| M. Scanlon | 1980 | Wore #53 in 1980 | ||
| Seiler | 1980 | |||
| B. Syer | 1982 | Norm Smith Squad in 1982 | ||
| Taylor | 1981 | Under 19s | ||
1990s
| Name | Year | Notes | ||
| Anderson | 1996 | R5 Reserves interchange. Possibly Daniel Anderson (Dandenong Stingrays). | ||
| Black | 1997 | |||
| Clarke | 1999 | |||
| B. Collins | 1998 | |||
| Cosson | 1995 | Interchange player in Round 20 Reserves game (Age 25/08/1995). Almost certainly David Cosson | ||
| Dimmatina | 1997 | Possibly Frankie | ||
| Evans | 1997 | |||
| Faulkner | 1996 | R5 Reserves interchange | ||
| Finnochiaro | 1997 | Possibly Tim Finnochiaro | ||
| M. Francis | 1991 | Possibly a misspelling of Fabian Francis | ||
| Garbers | 1997 | Possibly Toby Garbers | ||
| Gleeson | 1994 | |||
| Henderson | 1999 | |||
| Hewett | 1999 | Not Evan Hewett | ||
| Howlett | 1991-1992 | Possibly a misspelling of John Howat | ||
| Hussey | 1994 | |||
| Marsh | 1999 | |||
| McCaughan | 1997 | Reserves top-up player. | ||
| Murphy | 1997 | |||
| Murray | 1999 | |||
| M. Newton | 1999 | Possibly a misprint of Leigh Newton | ||
| O'Brien | 1995 | Interchange player in Round 20 Reserves game (Age 25/08/1995) | ||
| O'Callaghan | 1996 | Reserves top up player in Round 19 (Age 09/08/1996) | ||
| O'Dwyer | 1999 | |||
| Padley | 1997 | Reserves top-up player | ||
| Paris | 1994 | |||
| Roberts | 1996 | (Reserves)) top up player in Round 19 (Age 09/08/1996) | ||
| Robertson | 1996 | Reserves top up player in Round 19 (Age 09/08/1996). Possibly C. Robertson or Russell Robertson | ||
| C. Robertson | 1997 | |||
| Shaw | 1995 | Back pocket in Round 6 Reserves game (Age 05/05/1995) | ||
| Smith | 1999 | |||
| Street | 1998 | |||
| T. Weller | 1997 | |||
Unknown, non-players, and unconfirmed claims
| Name | Year | Notes | ||
| Agnew | 1900 | Honorary 'Surgeon' and also a Director. Photo uploaded. Not a player. | ||
| Roy Agresta | ? | Shown by Griffith FC to be 'ex Melbourne' but no other record | ||
| Bill Dalkins and Alan Trew | ? | Shown as 'Melbourne' players in 1952 but likely this was from the city of Melbourne not the team | ||
| S. Ferguson | 1945 | Medical officer until joining the navy | ||
| C. Harris | ? | Life Member in 2006 | ||
| W. Hislop | ? | Life Member in 1945. On the coaching staff in 1940 as B. Hislop | ||
| M. Hutchins | ? | Life Member in 1961 | ||
| L. Jones | ? | Life Member in 2005. Possibly Les Jones. | ||
| AA McDonald | ? | Pre-1930 | ||
| John McMahon | ? | Shown as Hawthorn pre-season player 1955 from Melbourne. | ||
| W. Murphy | ? | Life Member in 1945 | ||
| Newman | 1914 | Club doctor | ||
| T. Rule | 1940 | Coaching staff | ||
| Horrie Sandford | ? | Some sources say the Victorian cricketer also played for Melbourne | ||
| JO Smith | ? | Life Member in 2005 | ||
| T. Walsh | 1940 | Coaching staff. | ||
| AT Wasley | ? | Shown as attending a club reunion in 1932 alongside a list of confirmed ex-players. | ||
| R Wynd | ? | Life Member in 1945 | ||
| R. Wynne | 1940 | Coaching staff. Likely the same as R. Wynd | ||