| Name | Year | Notes
|
| A. Aitken | 1923 | Juniors
|
| H. Alberry | 1925 | From Caulfield in May 1925 and a seconds player. Incorrectly spelt Albert in some sources.
|
| Alexander | 1920 | Seconds player
|
| Alford | 1923 | Pre-season player who was leading goalkicker in his Gippsland district in 1922
|
| A. Allen | 1923 | Juniors
|
| G. Almond | 1920 | From Shepparton
|
| Andersen/Anderson | 1925 | Training list player
|
| Anderson | 1921 | Seconds
|
| C. Anderson | 1927 | To Brighton. Possibly this player
|
| J. Anthony | 1923 | Pre-season player from Tasmania
|
| S. Anthony | 1920 | Pre-season rover
|
| J. Archer | 1925 | Played in a seconds curtain raiser to an interstate game
|
| Arren | 1928 | Seconds
|
| Arthur | 1924 | Seconds
|
| Atkins | 1922 | Pre-season defender
|
| R. Atkins | 1925 | Played in a seconds curtain raiser to an interstate game
|
| Atkins | 1924 | Seconds. Probably same as R. Atkins.
|
| Atkins | 1926 | Seconds player. Probably same as R. Atkins and Atkins 1924
|
| Atkinson | 1924 | Seconds
|
| WR Banks | 1927-29 | Seconds player who applied for a clearance to Brighton in 1928. Cleared to Prahran in 1930. This Banks, probably not Jack Banks
|
| E. Barker | 1926 | From Collingwood. Possibly Fred Barker or a misspelling of Edward Baker. Possibly the F. Barker who went to Hawthorn in April 1927
|
| F. Barker | 1926 | Possibly the same as E. Barker. To Hawthorn in April 1927. Probably not Fred Barker.
|
| Barlow | 1922 | Pre-season wingman
|
| Bates | 1921 | Pre-season defender from Healesville
|
| GL Baxer | 1925 | From Prahran. Possibly Ray Baxter
|
| T. Beamish | 1928 | Follower from Alphington. Wore #22. Photo uploaded.
|
| Beckwith | 1924 | From Lang Lang
|
| V. Bell | 1922 | Possibly Frank Bell
|
| Ball/Bell | 1923 | Pre-season defender
|
| Beardsley | 1922 | Juniors player
|
| F. Bissett | 1923 | Juniors
|
| RV Bennetts | 1929 | From Jeparit before Round 12
|
| Bousie | 1922 | Seconds player
|
| Bowen | 1923 | Practice Matches
|
| Bowman | 1928 | Seconds
|
| J. Bowtell | 1927-28 | From Armadale. Seconds player. To Prahran in 1929. VFA Project profile
|
| Brake | 1925 | Training list player
|
| C. Bright | 1926 | Pre-season half back from Brunswick
|
| Britt | 1925 | Training list player from Windsor Fire Station or Williamstown. Almost certainly Gerry Britt
|
| Brown | 1922 | Juniors player
|
| Bruce | 1923 | Seconds | Cleared to Collingwood in May 1924
|
| Bruce | 1928 | Seconds half-back cleared to Prahran in 1929.
|
| Brumby | 1920-1921 | Seconds
|
| DG Bryan | 1920 | Probably not Claude Bryan
|
| R. Buckway | 1921 | pre-season centre/forward from Maryborough
|
| Burns | 1921 | Pre-season Seconds player
|
| P. Burke | 1922 | To Ballarat in April 1923
|
| Burnstihle | 1926 | Pre-season rover from Leopold
|
| Burt | 1925 |
|
| Call | 1922 | Pre-season defender
|
| Calleson | 1922 | Pre-season player
|
| C. Cameron | 1925-26 | Seconds forward from Orbost.
|
| Campbell | 1921 | Pre-season forward
|
| Campbell | 1923 | Pre-season and Juniors forward.
|
| J. Cannon | 1924-1925 | Seconds centre half-back. Injured ankle in Round 1, 1925
|
| O. Carr | 1929 | Seconds. Not Clem Carr
|
| Carroll | 1928 | Pre-season centre half-forward from the public service
|
| Carter | 1923 | [https://trove.nla.gov.au/newspaper/article/243797021 | Pre-season] player from Oakleigh. Brother of Wally Carter
|
| Carter | 1924 | Pre-season ruck-rover from Ulverstone
|
| F. Cayley | 1929 | From Moorabbin. Seconds.
|
| Chalmers | 1921 | Juniors player
|
| Chandler | 1926-27 | Pre-season player in 1927. Seconds in 1926.
|
| C. Chisholm | 1923 | Juniors
|
| Chrystal | 1921 | Seconds
|
| TA Clarke | 1929 | To Hawthorn in June
|
| Clements | 1923 | Practice match defender
|
| Clements | 1924 | Pre-season rover from Ferntree Gully
|
| Cochrane | 1922 | Seconds
|
| Cochrane | 1929 | Pre-season forward from Chelsea who kicked more than 100 goals the previous year
|
| N. Coe | 1928 | Seconds. From Brighton Seconds
|
| M. Collins | 1924 | Seconds
|
| Colliver | 1927 | Pre-season half back from Rushworth.
|
| Comber | 1921 | Pre-season Seconds player from Port Melbourne. Probably Mick Comber
|
| Colter | 1924 | Pre-season player from Charlton
|
| PJ Condon | 1929-30 | Follower/forward from South Yarra Juniors. Also shown as from Gippsland. Signed in July 1929. To South Melbourne in 1930.
|
| Connor | 1926 | Seconds player
|
| Conroy | 1921 | Pre-season Seconds player
|
| C. Coomber | 1926 | Cleared to the Seconds from Werribee
|
| Cornish | 1929 | Pre-season half back
|
| Coulter x2 | 1922 | Pre-season defender. Possibly Bill Coulter. Two players with the same surname trained.
|
| Cowden | 1925 | Pre-season winger
|
| Crowle | 1920 | Seconds
|
| Coyne | 1923 | Prfactice Match defender
|
| Crawford | 1928 | Pre-season player
|
| E. Croft | 1929 | To Northcote before Round 5
|
| Cronen | 1926 | Seconds
|
| JC Dennis | 1927-28 | Former Sandringham captain and half forward. Cleared to Nullawil before Round 4 1928
|
| W. Dillon | 1925-1926 | Played in a seconds curtain raiser to an interstate game. To Camberwell in April 1927. VFA Project profile
|
| Douglas | 1924 | Pre-season player. Wing/half-forward from the Juniors
|
| J. Drake | 1923-1925 | Juniors/Seconds ruckman
|
| Drew | 1929 | Pre-season forward from Williamstown. Either Con or Leo
|
| TH Druie | 1926 | From Maryborough.Rover
|
| Drummond | 1926 | Pre-season forward
|
| Deuer | 1927 | Pre-season player from Lilydale. Also shown as Geuer
|
| V. Dunan/Dunin/Dunnin/Dunwin/Dunim | 1925-1927 | Played in a seconds curtain raiser to an interstate game. Pre-season player in 1927 and 1928
|
| T. Durie | 1926 | Rover from Maryborough before R3 1926, to Coburg before R10 1926. VFA Project profile
|
| Eady | 1924-1925 | Seconds
|
| Eddy | 1924 | Backman from Melbourne Swimming Club. Probably the same as Eady.
|
| Eakins | 1926 | Pre-season follower from Canterbury
|
| S Edgar | 1929 | From NSW before Round 8
|
| Egan | 1924 | Pre-season rover from Kooweerup
|
| Elder/Eider | 1923 | Pre-season wingman
|
| Elliott | 1925 | Training list player
|
| W. Evans | 1925 | From Hawthorn
|
| Fagan | 1928 | Pre-season follower from Murrumbeena
|
| A. Findley | 1928 | Seconds. Recruited from unalloted area
|
| Finlayson | 1926 | Pre-season player
|
| Forness | 1920 | Seconds
|
| Forness | 1921, 1924 | Seconds. One of the Forness' was a rover.
|
| H. Forness | 1923-1926 | Juniors in 1923. To Camberwell in April 1927
|
| N. Forness | 1925 | Seconds
|
| Finlay | 1928 | Half forward. Also shown as Findlay in some sources.
|
| Fraser | 1923 | Pre-season full back
|
| Frazier | 1924 | Pre-season player from Albury
|
| Fulling | 1921, 1923-1924 | Seconds backman
|
| Furlong | 1923 | Practice matches. Half-back. Possibly Phil Furlong
|
| Gaby | 1924 | Seconds player
|
| Gall | 1922 | Pre-season follower from Euroa
|
| Gardiner | 1923 | Pre-season forward
|
| Geddes | 1921 | Juniors player, cleared to Williamstown in May 1922
|
| Geuer | 1927 | Pre-season player
|
| Gilder | 1920 | Seconds player
|
| Gilder | 1927 | Pre-season player
|
| W. Gillam | 1921 | Pre-season all-rounder from Mooroopna. Also shown as from Murchison
|
| Glenister | 1922 | Juniors player who joined Williamstown in 1923
|
| W. Godfrey | 1923 | Juniors
|
| Goding | 1932 | Pre-season winger from Oakleigh. Probably Fred Goding
|
| AE, EA or C. Gosstray/Gostray | 1925 | From Diamond Creek. Played in a seconds curtain raiser to an interstate game. Also listed as being from "the tramways". Defender
|
| Goldsworthy | 1929 | Tall forward from South Ballarat, recruited mid-season
|
| Gracie | 1929 | Pre-season forward from South Yarra
|
| JC Greening | 1925 | Cleared to Prahran. Possibly the same as JJ Greening. VFA Project profile
|
| JJ Greening | 1924 | Winger from Charlton. Seconds player.
|
| T. Greenwood | 1923-24 | Juniors
|
| Gregory | 1929 | Pre-season half-back/forward from Murrumbeena
|
| R. Griff/Grigg | 1921 | From Maldon or Malvern. Also shown as 'Gregg'.
|
| Gurney | 1924 | Pre-season defender from Gawler
|
| Hancock | 1924 | Player
|
| Hannon | 1927 | Played practice matches. From South Yarra.
|
| D. Harker | 1920 | From an 'unalloted district'
|
| Hales | 1920 | Seconds
|
| F. Hall | 1926 | Pre-season rover from Ballarat
|
| JJ Hall | 1921 | From an 'unalloted district'
|
| Hall | 1928 | Pre-season Naval Depot half-back
|
| N. Hardiman | 1928 | To St Kilda before Round 4
|
| Harris | 1929 | Pre-season half-forward from Dookie
|
| A.E Hart | 1929-1930 | From Port Melbourne. Originally cleared in July 1929. Centreman. VFA Project profile
|
| Hartley | 1921 | Pre-season forward
|
| Hazel/Hazzell | 1925 | Seconds player
|
| NG Heinke | 1929 | From Bruthen before Round 3. To Camberwell before Round 4. VFA Project profile
|
| WJ Herton | 1928 | Seconds. From Prahran.
|
| Hill | 1926 | Pre-season defender from Warburton
|
| Holmes | 1921 | Seconds
|
| F. Holmes | 1926 | Pre-season winger from Seymour
|
| Hore | 1928 | Half-back from Bentleigh. Possibly the same as Horton.
|
| WJ Horton | 1928 | Seconds from Prahran. VFA Project profile
|
| W. House | 1929 | From Dookie before Round 5
|
| Howell | 1921 | Pre-season Seconds player
|
| Howey | 1927 | Pre-season player from Port Melbourne Juniors. May be this Howey
|
| Hutchison/Hutchison | 1921 | Seconds winger. Also in 1922 pre-season
|
| Hutchinson | 1923 | Juniors
|
| Jack | 1922 | Pre-season player from South Yarra
|
| Jackson | 1924 | Seconds
|
| James | 1927-1928 | Ruckman who played Juniors then pre-season in 1928
|
| Jeffrey | 1921 | Seconds
|
| Jeffers | 1924 | From Lang Lang
|
| Johnston | 1922 | Pre-season defender
|
| Johnson | 1928 | Seconds
|
| Jones | 1926-1927 | Seconds player. Probably either C or T. Jones
|
| T. Jones | 1928-1929 | Seconds. Recruited from unalloted area. Probably T. Jones from 1929
|
| H. Jones | 1921 | Pre-season rover from Albury
|
| Joss | 1921 | Pre-season Seconds player
|
| J. Kavanagh | 1920 | Pre-season centre/rover from Terang
|
| G. Keady | 1921 | Pre-season all-rounder from Mooroopna
|
| JA Kearney | 1920 | Pre-season half back from Elsternwick
|
| R. Kelly | 1929 | From an unallotted area. To Hawthorn in June
|
| R. Kennedy | 1929 | From Old Xavs
|
| S. Kennedy | 1920 | Seconds player who broke his leg in a game in June
|
| Kennedy | 1929 | Second player from Warrnambool. Also appeared in 1930 pre-season.
|
| Kidd | 1928 | Pre-season forward from Alexandra
|
| Knipp | 1921 | Seconds
|
| AE Keyhoe | 1929-1930 | Cleared from from Port Melbourne in June 1929 after playing seconds.Seconds also in 1930. To Port Melbourne in May 1930. VFA Project profile. Also shown as 'Keogh'
|
| Kercheval | 1926 | Pre-season forward from Warburton. Likely Ronald Kercheval.
|
| Kyhoe | 1927 | Pre-season player from Preston. Possibly same as Keyhoe/Keogh.
|
| J. Lake | 1927 | From Fitzroy. Maybe Jim Lake
|
| King | 1929 | Pre-season wingman from Eaglehawk who played for Bendigo League against VFL in 1928
|
| D. Lang | 1921 | From Wonthaggi in July
|
| EV Langwell | 1929 | From Brunswick, and back to Brunswick before Round 9. VFA Project profile. Originally from Fitzroy Juniors.
|
| Latham | 1925 | Training list player from Hawthorn/Oakleigh. Probably not Bill Latham
|
| Lawrence | 1926-1927 | Seconds player from North Melbourne. Also shown as from South Melbourne Juniors
|
| Layley | 1929 | Pre-season half-forward from Murrumbeena
|
| W. Lee | 1923-1924 | Seconds - To Collingwood in June 1924
|
| Lester | 1923-1924 | Pre-season defender in 1923 and seconds player in 1924. Possibly Fred Lester
|
| Leston | 1925 | Training list player
|
| JC Little | 1928 | From North Melbourne Laurels
|
| Lloyd | 1921 | Pre-season Seconds player
|
| Loch | 1928 | Pre-season follower
|
| Loh | 1921-1922 | Juniors half back
|
| London | 1928-1929 | Pre-season forward from Sandringham who was injured in 1928 trial games then returned again in 1929.
|
| F. Luttrell | 1928 | Winger from South Yarra. Wore #36. Son of the curator of the MCG
|
| Lyons | 1921 | Pre-season and seconds player. A policeman
|
| Lyms | 1926 | Seconds player
|
| Lyte | 1923 | Seconds. May have been a returning Bill Lyte.
|
| MacFarlane | 1927 | Pre-season wingman from Scotch College/Old Scotch
|
| B. MacGregor | 1929 | From St Kilda
|
| MacLeod | 1925 | Seconds
|
| Maguire | 1923 | Practice match forward
|
| A. Mahon | 1923 | Juniors
|
| L. Makeham | 1924 | From Woodleigh. Pre-season player and brother of a Collingwood player
|
| Marshall | 1922 | Pre-season follower from Brunswick Juniors
|
| Marr | 1929 | Seconds
|
| P. Marshall | 1926 | Pre-season rover from South Yarra Juniors. Recommended by Dick Taylor
|
| W. Martin | 1921 | Pre-season backman from Scotch College. Likely an Old Scotch player, but potentially a Charles Fredrick 'Billie' Martin who attended Scotch to 1915.
|
| G. Matheson | 1926 | Pre-season forward from South Yarra. Recommended by Ivor Warne-Smith
|
| Matthews | 1923 | Pre-season half back. May have been Herb Matthews
|
| May | 1921 | Seconds
|
| McCarthy | 1922 | Pre-season player from Monbulk
|
| J. McColl | 1924-1925 | Played in a seconds curtain raiser to an interstate game
|
| McComb/McCombe | 1921 | Seconds
|
| R. McDonald | 1920-1922 | Winger from Alphington. To Williamstown in June 1922
|
| WA McDonald | 1929 | Pre-season half-back from Albury. Photo uploaded.
|
| McDonald | 1929 | Seconds ruckman
|
| McDougall | 1929 | Pre-season player from Sandringham. Probably Roy McDougall
|
| McGregor | 1924 | Pre-season player and brother of an Adelaide champion
|
| B. McGregor | 1929 | From St Kilda Seconds to MFC seconds
|
| A. McInnes | 1926-1927 | Pre-season and seconds forward. Nephew of George Haines. Spelt McGuiness in some sources. 18-years-old in 1926. To Port Melbourne in 1928. Also spelt McInnes. Possibly Geoff McInnes
|
| A. McLoughlin | 1926 | Pre-season rover from Benalla
|
| M. McIsaac | 1921 | Pre-season follower from Mooroopna
|
| McIver | 1928 | Seconds
|
| L. McMahon | 1926 | From Ballarat Imperials. Required a clearance from Essendon. To Hawthorn in 1927. Seconds winger.
|
| McRae | 1928 | Seconds
|
| McRae | 1929 | Pre-season centre-half forward from Melbourne Grammar
|
| R. Meade | 1928 | Seconds. Possibly a misspelling of L. Meade.
|
| Meekin/Meeking | 1923 | Pre-season defender
|
| McMeekin | 1925 | Pre-season forward from Kerang
|
| Middleditch | 1923 | Pre-season Ballarat junior who kicked 52 goals for his club in 1922
|
| J. Moody | 1928 | From Echuca
|
| Monks | 1924 | Pre-Season player
|
| More | 1923 | Juniors
|
| G. Moore | 1928 | Seconds. From Unalloted district. Like the G. Moore cleared to North Melbourne in 1932.
|
| E. Moore | 1925 | To Richmond in July 1925
|
| Mullins | 1923 | Pre-season centreman
|
| Murray | 1928 | Pre-season player from Bendigo. Possibly Wyn Murray.
|
| Nelson | 1923-24 | Practice Matches https://trove.nla.gov.au/newspaper/article/243786969 and Pre-Season player
|
| W. Newsome | 1920 | Pre-season contender for a ruck position from Dandenong
|
| KW Nicholson | 1921 | To Geelong in July 1921
|
| G. Nylander | 1926-28 | From Ballarat. Cleared back to Ballarat before R1 1929
|
| F. O'Brien | 1925 | Possibly the same as L. O'Brien from 1925. To Richmond before R1 1926. Probably Frank O'Brien.
|
| O'Brien | 1923 | From St Kevins. Half-forward.
|
| L. O'Brien | 1925 | Played in a seconds curtain raiser to an interstate game. Probably the 1926-27 O'Brien.
|
| O'Brien | 1926-1927 | Seconds player. Also played midweek games with the Postal Employees. Probably the same as L. O'Brien. Not Tom O'Brien.
|
| FH O'Callaghan | 1925 | First clearance refused. Newspaper says from North Melbourne, Football Record says from Essendon. Sporting Globe says from Oakleigh. Appeared on training list. May be more than one O'Callaghan.
|
| O'Connell | 1924 | From Lang Lang
|
| O'Connor | 1926 | Pre-season half forward from Fish Creek
|
| O'Halloran | 1929 | Pre-season wingman From Wangaratta. Also shown as a ruck/defender.
|
| O'Neill | 1920 | Half-back/centre who trained late in season. From Hastings.
|
| Ockwell | 1925 | Training list player
|
| Ohlen | 1927 | Pre-season player from Preston
|
| Oldham | 1923 | Pre-season defender
|
| Organ | 1928 | Former NSW state player. Defender
|
| Pardy | 1922 | Pre-season half-forward flank
|
| Parker | 1923-1924 | Seconds
|
| Parker | 1926 | Junior player cleared to Geelong Association in 1927
|
| A. Pearson | 1923 | Juniors
|
| Pebarfald | 1920 | Seconds
|
| TA Pert | 1928 | Forward who wore #24. From Elsternwick. Also shown as Peart in some sources
|
| FG Porter | 1924 | Follower From Ulverstone. Clearance initially refused a week earlier (Age 24/04/1924) because he hadn't completed 12 months in Victoria. Also centre half-forward.
|
| FV Porter | 1925 | To St Kilda in June 1925.
|
| HC/HE Proctor | 1923-24 | From Charlton. To Prahran in May 1924. VFA Project profile
|
| Pulling | 1921 | Pre-season Seconds ruckman
|
| Prunier | 1922 | Pre-season player. Possibly Bill Brunier
|
| Rea | 1929 | Pre-season player
|
| Reeves | 1920-1921 | Seconds player. Also shown as Reeves.
|
| Rees | 1925 | Training list player
|
| Rice | 1928 | Seconds
|
| Richardson | 1927 | Half forward. Played practice matches. From Geelong Association or Geelong Juniors. Also shown as from Port Melbourne
|
| Roberts | 1929 | Seconds
|
| Robertson | 1921 | Seconds
|
| R Rooke | 1926 | From Tasmania
|
| Rosbach | 1921-1923 | Played Juniors. Also shown as Rosback. Said to have 'returned' in early 1922. Ruckman.
|
| R. Rourke | 1926 | Pre-season back from Tasmania
|
| Russell | 1920 | Seconds player
|
| J. Ryan | 1923 | Juniors
|
| H. Salisbury | 1926 | Pre-season forward from Prahran Juniors
|
| RD/WD Schrader/Shraeder | 1928 | From Hawthorn. To St Kilda Seconds in 1929
|
| Schafer | 1929 | Seconds
|
| W. Scott | 1924 | To Rutherglen in April 1925. Possibly Wally Scott
|
| Scrithen | 1925 | Seconds
|
| Sewell | 1923 | Pre-season defender
|
| Shake | 1920 | Seconds player
|
| Sharp | 1928 | Pre-season University half back.
|
| Sharpley | 1926 | Pre-season forward from Flying School
|
| H. Shekan | 1927 | From Wangaratta
|
| Sheridan | 1921 | Seconds player from Brighton. Back to Brighton in July. VFA Project profile. Also shown as from Prahran District.
|
| L. Shinkfield | 1924-1926 | Seconds backman who played in a seconds curtain raiser to an interstate game
|
| Silivia/Silveria | 1928-29 | Seconds
|
| E. Simmonds | 1929 | Pre-season player from Murtoa
|
| W. or H. Slatter | 1923-24 | Juniors in 1923 and 1924. Possibly two different people. 1924 version was a firefighter. Broke his kneecap in early-1924 but a Slatter plays Seconds in June.
|
| Skater | 1924 | Player
|
| P. Smith | 1928 | Seconds. To Prahran in 1929.
|
| Smith | 1924 | From Lang Lang
|
| G. Smith | 1925 | Pre-season half-back from Dimboola
|
| South | 1923 | Practice matches
|
| A. Southam | 1921-1923 | Juniors ruckman
|
| Southern | 1924 | Seconds forward. Probably the same as A. Southam
|
| Sprague | 1922-23 | Half-forward promoted from the MFC Juniors for 1923 pre-season. Possibly the same as J. Sprigg. Probably Jim Sprigg or Eric Sprague
|
| Stanley | 1928 |
|
| Standish | 1926 | Pre-season player
|
| F. Stanley | 1926 | To Dimboola in April 1927
|
| Stokes | 1924 | Seconds player. Wingman
|
| AJ Sullivan | 1925 | Seconds player from Port Melbourne. Probably not Jimmy Sullivan.
|
| W. Sweeney | 1923 | Pre-season and Juniors
|
| Tabart | 1928 | Seconds
|
| Tate | 1921 | Pre-season Seconds player
|
| Tatham | 1926 | Pre-season player
|
| Taylor | 1920-1921 | Seconds player
|
| K. Taylor | 1923 | WA athlete who transferred to Melbourne for work to try and qualify for an athletics carnival in London. From West Perth. Appeared in pre-season games. Also shown as W. Taylor
|
| Taylor | 1925 | Training list player
|
| Thomas | 1921 | Pre-season defender from Mitcham. Probably Ted Thomas - definitely not Enos Thomas
|
| R. Thomas | 1925 | Played in a seconds curtain raiser to an interstate game
|
| Thompson | 1927 | North Adelaide rover who trialed in the pre-season. Probably John Thompson.
|
| P. Tierney | 1920 | Pre-season contender for a ruck spot from Northcote. VFA Project profile
|
| Tory | 1925 | Training list player
|
| Tucker | 1921 | Pre-season
|
| Walker | 1921 | Pre-season defender. Possibly George Walker
|
| Warren | 1928-1929 | Reserves player to Sandringham in 1930
|
| S. Waterman | 1929 | From Brighton Vale
|
| Waters | 1937 | Pre-season player
|
| Watson | 1921 | Seconds
|
| Weaver | 1923 | Practice Matches
|
| R. Webb | 1923 | Juniors
|
| West | 1926 | Pre-season player from Mentone
|
| Whalley | 1929 | Pre-season player from Williamstown
|
| White | 1922 | Pre-season defender. Probably JL White
|
| White | 1923-1924 | Broke his arm in 1923.
|
| R. White | 1925 | Played in a seconds curtain raiser to an interstate game
|
| V. Whiteley/Whitlely | 1929 | Seconds wing
|
| T. Whitfield | 1923 | Juniors
|
| SG Wigg | 1928 | To St Kilda before R1 1929
|
| Wilkins | 1926 | Pre-season forward from Williamstownn - injured an ankle in a trial game VFA Project profile
|
| F. Willett | 1921 | pre-season player from Ararat
|
| Williams | 1923 | Pre-season forward
|
| Wilson | 1920 | Seconds player
|
| C. Wilson | 1921 | Pre-season follower from Brighton. Possibly Clarrie Wilson
|
| E. Wilson | 1923 | Pre-season forward/wingman
|
| Wise | 1924 | Seconds player and defender from Ballarat.
|
| Woodman | 1924 | From Rosedale
|
| Woods | 1920 | Seconds
|
| Woods | 1921 | Pre-season defender from Caulfield
|
| RS Woodhouse | 1928 | Wore #34. Pre-season half-forward from Mentone who appeared in seconds games. To Eaglehawk in 1929, then St Kilda in 1930. Also shown as P 'Woolhouse'
|
| Wright | 1923 | Pre-season defender. May have been M or W Wright from 1925.
|
| Young | 1928 | Seconds. Possibly the same as C. Young from 1925 or the Young from 1930. Possibly Charles Young
|
| CE Young | 1925 | From an unallotted districted. Played in a seconds curtain raiser to an interstate game. Possibly Charles Young |