VFL/AFL
Most games: 150 - Matthew Whelan
Most goals: 131 - Ricky Jackson
| Player | Years | Notes |
| Peter Baker | 1960 | |
| John Quirk | 1966 | |
| Danny Jennings | 1969-1970 | |
| Henry Ritterman | 1971-1972 | #22 in 1973 |
| Greg MacDonald | 1973 | |
| Peter Giles | 1979 | #4 1980 to 1987 |
| Russell Dickson | 1981 | |
| Glenn Boland | 1983 | #27 in 1984 |
| Graeme Yeats | 1984 | #8 from 1985 to 1995 |
| Ricky Jackson | 1986-1991 | |
| Wayne Lamb | 1992 | |
| Todd McHardy | 1996-1997 | |
| Troy Longmuir | 1999 | |
| Matthew Whelan | 2000-2009 | |
| Matt Jones | 2013-2016 | |
| Declan Keilty | 2019 | |
No senior games
| Player | Years | |
| John King | 1959 | |
| Garry Breen | 1961-1962 | |
| Jim Whitelaw | 1963 | |
| Brian Vaughan | 1964 | Also Number 50 in 1964 |
| J. Snell | 1964 | |
| Denis Farr | 1967 | |
| Greg Smith | 1968 | |
| Ian Glenn | 1974 | |
| Brian Volkering | 1974 | |
| Greg Withers | 1975 | Number 42 in 1976 |
| Robert Walters | 1976 | Number 32 in 1977 and 16 between 1978-1981 |
| Peter Geddes | 1977 | Number 50 in 1976 |
| Barry Besanko | 1977 | |
| George Quine | 1977 | |
| Geoff Clarke | 1978 | |
| Alf Boccabella | 1978 | |
| Ross Goodman | 1980 | |
| Shane Ward | 1985-1986 | |
| Daniel Clarke | 1993 | Number 30 in 1994 |
| Justin Pascoe | 1994 | |
| Trent Ormond-Allen | 1994 | Number 35 from 1995 to 1996 |
| Kelvin Lawrence | 2011-2012 | |
| Andy Moniz-Wakefield | 2022- |