| VFL/AFL | AFLW | |
VFL/AFL
Most games: 227 - Norm Smith
Most goals: 572 - Norm Smith
| Player | Years | Notes |
| Jim Fitzpatrick | 1912 | #12 in 1913 |
| Bill McKenzie | 1913 and 1919 | #6 in 1912, #27 in 1914, #18 in 1915 |
| Percy Colee | 1914 | |
| Tim Collins | 1915 | #24 in 1914 |
| Alec Farrow | 1920 | #24 in 1919, 28 in 1921 |
| Francis Lyon | 1921 | |
| Alf Oldham | 1922 | |
| Tom Elliott | 1923-1924 | |
| Jimmy Abernethy | 1926-1932 | #14 from 1923 to 1924 |
| Jack Sambell | 1933-1934 | |
| Norm Smith | 1935-1948 | |
| Bob Chadwick | 1949 | |
| Jack Hiscock | 1950 | |
| Ken Christie | 1951-1955 | |
| John Lord | 1957-1965 | |
| Peter Smith | 1966-1967 | |
| Tony Sullivan | 1968-1979 | #43 in 1967 |
| Peter Giles | 1980-1987 | #45 in 1979 |
| Tony Campbell | 1988-1991 | #40 from 1986 to 1987 |
| Chris Sullivan | 1992-1994 | |
| Andrew Obst | 1995-1997 | #29 from 1990 to 1994 |
| Brent Grgic | 1998-2001 | #48 in 1997 |
| Craig Ellis | 2002-2003 | |
| Ben Holland | 2004-2008 | |
| Jack Watts | 2009-2017 | |
| James Harmes | 2018-2023 | |
| Judd McVee | 2024- | #41 in 2023 |
AFLW
Most games: 72 - Paxy Paxman
Most goals: 26 - Paxy Paxman
| Player | Years | Notes |
| Paxy Paxman | 2017 - |