The following players have worn jersey number 54 in a VFL/AFL premiership match.
Most games: 9 - Brent Heaver
Most goals: 10 - Brent Heaver
| Player | Years | Notes |
| Peter Williamson | 1972 | #49 in 1971, #30 from 1973 to 1974 |
| Neil Chamberlain | 1973 | #14 from 1974 to 1976 |
| Mike Power | 1974 | |
| Trevor Korn | 1981 | |
| Brent Heaver | 1990 | #38 in 1991 |
| James McDonald | 1997 | #23 from 1998 to 2010 |
Players who didn't play a senior match
| Player | Years | Notes |
| Kevin McNamee | 1965 | |
| A. Moller | 1966 | |
| G. Woods | 1971 | |
| Michael Lutterell | 1974 | |
| David Green | 1974 | |
| Michael Giulieri | 1976 | #16 in 1978 |
| Michael Baldwin | 1977 | |
| Peter Maynard | 1979 | #36 in 1980-1981 |
| Tony Kelly | 1980 | |
| Glenn McKissack | 1980 | |
| Mark Fisher | 1982 | |
| Tony Mazurek | 1983 | |
| Joe Rugolo | 1983 | #53 and #26 in 1985, #26 from 1986-1987 |
| Scott Sutcliffe | 1984 | #44 in 1982-1983 |
| Paul McCarty | 1984 | |
| Dale Lawrence | 1985 | #60 in 1986 and #56 in 1987 |
| Peter McCarty | 1986 | #55 in 1985 and #49 in 1987 |
| Glen Kiley | 1987 | |
| Brett Minchington | 1988 | |
| Matthew Power | 1989 | |
| Leigh Capsalis | 1991 | |
| Michael Coutts | 1992 | |
| Bruce Cohen | 1993 | |
| Lee Anderson | 1998 | |
| Anthony Ferraro | 1998-1999 | |