Saturday June 6 - MCG
Crowd - 5000-9000
Hotham 0.8 (half time 0.2 to 0.1)
Melbourne win by 3 goals
Goalkickers: Coulson 1, Collie 1, McCrindle 1
After five losses against senior sides in a row to start their season, Melbourne got a larger than expected crowd to see their first victory after the cancellation of a nearby Essendon vs South Melbourne match.
The unbeaten Hotham were expected to extend Melbourne's misery in easy fashion, but the state of the wet ground after 48 hours of rain suited the lighter home side and they gave Hotham their first loss of the year. The oval was in such a condition that players could barely keep their feet, but Melbourne played the ice-rink like conditions far better.
Hotham kicked with the wind in the first half, and in the first three minutes the conditions became even more farcical when rain started falling. The nimbler Reds attacked first but could only register a behind, and for much of the first half the ball was stuck on the south wing in three inches of water. Only the backmen managed to avoided going into half time covered in mud, and Melbourne's defenders had little to do in the second half as their forwards took over and kicked three goals while the visitors were kept scoreless - including a disallowed goal.
Best were Howard Morrison, Carroll and Edwards.
Some sources have Taylor scoring a goal instead of Collie and give Melbourne's final score as 3.8