For Melbourne
| Player | Opponent | Game | Result |
| Lance Arnold | North Melbourne | Round 5, 1949 | Out on the full to lose |
| Ron Barassi Sr | Geelong | Round 10, 1940 | Behind to lose |
| Ron Baggott | Collingwood | Round 16, 1935 | Goal to draw |
| Steven Clark | Essendon | Round 11, 1991 | Fell short to lose |
| Jayden Hunt | Geelong | Round 1, 2018 | Fell short to lose |
Against Melbourne
| Player | Opponent | Game | Result |
| Bert Whittington | Geelong | Round 2, 1911 | Behind to draw |
| Bert Smedley | St. Kilda | Round 17, 1928 | Goal to win |
| Vin Arthur | Carlton | Round 15, 1930 | Fell short to lose |
| Noel Teasdale | North Melbourne | Round 16, 1967 | Fell short to lose |
| Alastair Clarkson | North Melbourne | Round 15, 1987 | Goal to win |
| Gary Buckenara | Hawthorn | Preliminary Final 1987 | Goal to win |
| Jeff Farmer | Fremantle | Round 8, 2002 | Goal to win |
| Matthew Egan | Geelong | Round 20, 2005 | Missed to lose |
| Jordan McMahon | Richmond | Round 18, 2009 | Goal to win |
| Tom Lynch | Gold Coast | Round 19, 2016 | Missed to lose |
| Zac Tuohy | Geelong | Round 18, 2018 | Goal to win |