VFL/AFL
Most games: 99 - Bernie Massey
Most goals: 26 - Jim Mitchell
| Player | Years | Notes |
| George Cassidy | 1929-1931 | |
| Bryan Crimmins | 1944 | |
| Jack Maher | 1944 | #14 from 1938 to 1940 |
| Frank Kennedy | 1945 | #39 in 1944, #17 from 1946-1947 |
| Jim Mitchell | 1946-1947 | #1 in 1948 |
| Mike Woods | 1949-1953 | |
| Terry Mountain | 1957 | |
| Bernie Massey | 1960-1967 | |
| Darryl Schwarz | 1968-1969 | |
| Bruce Brown | 1971 | |
| John Reid | 1972-1974 | |
| Ted Carroll | 1975-1977 | #42 in 1974 |
| Glenn Giles | 1981 | |
| David Allday | 1985-1986 | |
| Jim Stynes | 1987 | #11 from 1988-1998 |
| David Flintoff | 1988-1991 | |
| Andrew Lamprill | 1992-1997 | |
| Luke Ottens | 1999 | |
| Brad Miller | 2002-2003 | #7 from 2004-2010 |
| Matthew Warnock | 2006-2009 | #1 from 2010 |
| Max Gawn | 2011-2014 | #11 from 2015 |
| Aaron vandenBerg | 2015-2016 | #22 from 2017 |
| Kade Chandler | 2019- | |
No senior games
| Player | Years | Notes |
| Fred Goding | 1928 | |
| Mark Lockwood | 1978 | #36 in 1979 |
| Wayne Parish | 1980 | |
| Robert Lawson | 1982 | |
| Bruce Joycey | 1983-1984 | |
| Shannon O'Brien | 2001 | #51 in 2000 |
| Paul Newman | 2004 | |
| Dion Johnstone | 2017-2018 | |