| VFL/AFL | AFLW | |
VFL/AFL
Most games: 143 - Matthew Febey
Most goals: 49 - Graeme Jacobs
| Player | Years | Notes |
| Wally Sykes | 1912 | |
| Harry Cope | 1913 | #18 in 1912 |
| Aubrey MacKenzie | 1914 | |
| Eric Parsons | 1914 | |
| George Walker | 1915 and 1920-1921 | #26 in 1914, #16 in 1919 |
| Teddy Johnson | 1919 | #23 in 1915 |
| Art McWhinney | 1919 | |
| Joe O'Carroll | 1920 | |
| Alf Wilson | 1921-1925 | |
| Bill Shelton | 1925 | #30 in 1919, #13 from 1920-1924 |
| Les Meade | 1927-1928 | |
| Harry Long | 1929-1937 | |
| Jack Coolahan | 1937 | |
| Frank Williams | 1938-1941 | |
| Ted Wood | 1942 | |
| Bob Herbert | 1943-1944 | |
| Harry New | 1945 | #31 in 1944 |
| George Lenne | 1945 | #13 from 1941-1942 |
| Norm Wilson | 1946 | #30 in 1945 |
| Russ Robinson | 1947-1948 | |
| Alan McGowan | 1949-1950 | #33 in 1948 |
| Tom McLean | 1951-1952 | |
| Graeme Pinfold | 1957-1961 | |
| Graeme Jacobs | 1964-1967 | |
| Paul Rowlands | 1969-1970 | |
| Laurie Queay | 1972 | |
| Shane McSpeerin | 1973 | #50 in 1971-1972 |
| Paul Hurst | 1975-1977 | |
| Brian Cook | 1977 | |
| Graham Gaunt | 1978-1982 | |
| Russell Richards | 1983-1987 | |
| Matthew Febey | 1992-2000 | |
| Troy Broadbridge | 2001-2004 | |
| Colin Garland | 2007-2016 | |
| Corey Maynard | 2018 | #48 in 2017 |
| Adam Tomlinson | 2020-2024 | |
| Xavier Lindsay | 2025- |
No senior games
| Player | Years | Notes |
| Wally Sykes | 1912 | Also wore #12 in 1912 |
| F. Bishop | 1942 | |
| Ted Fay | 1943 | |
| Kevan Hamilton | 1955 | |
AFLW
Most games: 15 - Brenna Tarrant
Most goals: 1 - Brenna Tarrant
| Player | Years | Notes |
| Claudia Whitfort | 2018 - 2019 | |
| Brenna Tarrant | 2020 - 2022 summer | |
| Charlotte Wilson | 2022 spring - 2023 | |
| Maggie Mahony | 2025 - | |
No senior games
| Player | Years | Notes |
| Pepa Randall | 2017 |