| VFL/AFL | AFLW | |
VFL/AFL
Most games: 254 - Brad Green
Most goals: 350 - Brad Green
| Player | Years | Notes |
| Arthur Ferguson | 1912 | |
| Harry Cope | 1912 | |
| Jack Bristow | 1913 | #14 in 1912 |
| Jim Mackie | 1913 | |
| Bill Daly | 1913 | #10 in 1914 |
| Les Smith | 1914 | |
| Bill McKenzie | 1915 | #6 in 1912, #4 in 1913 and 1919, #27 in 1914 |
| Stan Huntington | 1919 | |
| Bob Bodington | 1920 | #28 in 1919 |
| Percy Tulloh | 1921-1927 | |
| Alec Proudfoot | 1929 | |
| Bill Cutler | 1930-1931 | |
| Don Hooper | 1932-1935 | #1 in 1943 |
| Wally Lock | 1936-1941 | |
| Darcy Walsh | 1942-1944 | |
| Bill Scanlan | 1943 | #38 in 1944, #19 from 1945-1948 |
| Adrian Dullard | 1945 | #34 from 1940-1943, #28 from 1946-1949 |
| Nevin Paynter | 1950-1951 and 1953 | |
| Harry Lack | 1952 | |
| Robert B Johnson | 1954-1956 | #16 from 1957-1961 |
| Kevin Mithen | 1957-1958 | |
| Brian Roet | 1961-1965 | #23 in 1968 |
| Neville Stone | 1966-1969 | |
| Des Campbell | 1970 | #5 from 1975-1977 |
| John Tilbrook | 1971-1975 | |
| Maurice Wingate | 1976-1980 | |
| Greg Hutchison | 1982-1984 | #52 in 1975, #43 from 1971-1981 |
| Steven Stretch | 1986-1993 | |
| Sean Charles | 1994 | #44 from 1992-1993, #1 from 1995-1997 |
| Craig Nettelbeck | 1996-1997 | |
| Matthew Bishop | 1999 | #48 in 1998 |
| Brad Green | 2000-2012 | |
| Daniel Cross | 2014-2015 | |
| Jake Melksham | 2017- |
No senior games
| Player | Years | Notes |
| Glen Moulton | 1980 | Also wore number 47 in the same year |
| Brad Hall | 1995 |
AFLW
Most games: 48 - Casey Sherriff
Most goals: 9 - Casey Sherriff
| Player | Years | Notes |
| Mel Hickey | 2017 - 2018 | |
| Casey Sherriff | 2019 - 2023 | Also on 2018 list |
| Denby Taylor | 2024 | |