The following players didn't accept payment for matches. Some only played part of their career (shown below where known) as amateurs. This list is a work in progress
| Player | Years |
| George Bickford | 1945-1946 |
| Artie Cambridge | 1922 |
| John Clennett | 1972-1974 |
| Denis Cordner | 1943, 1948-1956 |
| Vin Coutie | 1901-1911 |
| David Hone | 1969 |
| Frank Jorgensen | 1925-1927 |
| Bryan Kenneally | 1959 |
| Ken Melville | 1953-1956 |
| Derek Mollison | 1923-1928 |
| Bobby Monk | 1907-1914 |
| Joe Pearce | 1904-1913 |
| Brian Roet | 1961-1968 |
| Alby Rodda | 1939* |
| Geoff Tunbridge | 1957-1962 |
| Francis Vine | 1926-1934 |
| Barney Wood | 1928 |
| Mike Woods | 1949-1953 |
Notes
George Bickford and Alby Rodda - may have played as an amateur for longer than indicated.