| VFL/AFL | AFLW | |
VFL/AFL
Most games: 286 - Nathan Jones
Most goals: 311 - Robert Flower
| Player | Years | Notes |
| Harry Brereton | 1912 | #7 in 1915 |
| Algy Millhouse | 1913 | |
| Billy Quinn | 1914 | |
| Percy Rodriguez | 1915 | |
| Eric Tonkin | 1919-1920 | |
| Joe Flanagan | 1921-1924 | |
| Clarrie Wyatt | 1925 | |
| Barney Wood | 1928 | |
| Wyn Murray | 1929-1934 | |
| Joe Kinnear | 1934 | #17 in 1932, #15 in 1933, #36 in 1935, #6 1936 to 1937 |
| Colin Niven | 1935 | #10 in 1933, #1 in 1934 |
| Lou Reiffel | 1936-1939 | |
| Roy Dowsing | 1942-1946 | |
| Dave Newman | 1947 | |
| Robert McKenzie Snr | 1948-1955 | |
| Alan Rowarth | 1958-1963 | |
| Robert Stewart | 1966-1967 | |
| Rob Dowsing | 1968 | #38 from 1966-1967 |
| Denis Clark | 1969-1970 | #38 in 1968, #17 from 1971-1975 |
| Robert McKenzie | 1971-1972 | #50 in 1969, #10 in 1970 |
| Robert Flower | 1973-1987 | |
| Stephen Tingay | 1992-1999 | #52 in 1989, #15, 1990 to 1991 |
| Steven Armstrong | 2002-2005 | |
| Nathan Jones | 2006-2021 | |
| Jacob van Rooyen | 2023 | #21 in 2022 |
No senior games
| Player | Years | Notes |
| Kevin Burke | 1947 | |
| Les Whyte | 1956-1957 | |
| Peter Wood | 1964-1965 | |
AFLW
Most games: 31 - Olivia Purcell
Most goals: 5 - Olivia Purcell
| Player | Years | Notes |
| Meg Downie | 2017 AFLW season - 2021 | |
| Olivia Purcell | 2022 summer - |