| VFL/AFL | AFLW | |
VFL/AFL
Most games: 204 - Ron Barassi
Most goals: 295 - Ron Barassi
| Player | Years | Notes |
| Tom Wellington | 1912 | #27 in 1913 |
| Frank Ellis | 1913 | Also wore #30 in 1913 |
| Jack Woolley | 1914 | |
| Leo Little | 1919 | #3 in1 920 |
| Reg Ellis | 1920 | |
| Fred Long | 1921-1922 | |
| Marcus Glasscock | 1923-1924 | |
| Col Deane | 1925-1930 | |
| Lew Gough | 1931 | #39 in 1930 |
| Jack Power | 1932-1934 | #12 from 1930-1931 |
| Ron Barassi Sr. | 1936-1940 | |
| Les Gibbs | 1941-1942 | #27 in 1939 |
| Harry New | 1944 | #20 in 1945 |
| Frank Hughes | 1945 | |
| Jack Mitchell | 1945 | |
| Stan Rule | 1946-1950 | |
| Ron Barassi Jr. | 1953-1964 | |
| Ray Groom | 1965-1968 | #15 from 1963-1964 |
| Billy Barham | 1974-1975 | |
| Paul Goss | 1976 | |
| Peter Garratt | 1978 | |
| Phil Carman | 1979 | |
| Kelvin Templeton | 1983-1985 | |
| Rod Keogh | 1990-1992 | |
| Donald Cockatoo-Collins | 1996-1998 | |
| Paul Wheatley | 2000-2009 | |
| Tom Scully | 2010-2011 | |
| Jack Grimes | 2013-2016 | |
| Bayley Fritsch | 2018- | |
No senior games
| Player | Years | Notes |
| Alf George | 1914 | #3 in 1912, #14 in 1913 and #29 1915 |
| Wally Power | 1935 | |
| Chris Walker | 1970 | #44 in 1971 |
| Hilton Stephenson | 1971 | #52 in 1971 |
| Ron Thomas | 1971 | |
| John Pilkington | 1972-1973 |
AFLW
Most games: 22 - Blaithin Mackin
Most goals: 5 - Blaithin Mackin
| Player | Years | Notes |
| Krstel Petrevski | 2020 - 2022 summer | |
| Blaithin Mackin | 2022 spring - |
No senior games
| Player | Years | Notes |
| Jordann Hickey | 2019 |