| VFL/AFL | AFLW | ||
VFL/AFL
Most games: 286 - David Neitz
Most goals: 614 - David Neitz
| Player | Years | Notes | |
| Bobby Monk | 1912 | #5 in 1913, #16 in 1914 | |
| Bill Allen | 1913 and 1915 | #1 in 1912 and 1919-1923, #19 in 1914 | |
| Harry Britter | 1914 | ||
| John McMahon | 1919 | ||
| Charlie Streeter | 1920-1928 | ||
| Howard Steel | 1930-1931 | #30 in 1932 | |
| Arthur Dickens | 1932 | ||
| Charlie Longhurst | 1933-1936 | ||
| Richie Emselle | 1937=1943 | ||
| Ivan Porter | 1944-1946 | ||
| Eddie Craddock | 1947 | #6 from 1948–1950 | |
| Les Crawley | 1948 | ||
| Colin Cox | 1949 | #26 in 1948 | |
| Ray Harvey | 1949 | ||
| Con O'Toole | 1950 | ||
| Alan Daly | 1951 | ||
| Max Orr | 1952-1953 | ||
| Peter Schofield | 1953 | ||
| Brian Dixon | 1954-1968 | ||
| George Lakes | 1969-1972 | #39 in 1968 | |
| Peter Yeo | 1972 | ||
| Stephen Kerley | 1973-1974 | #49 in 1971, #41 in 1972 | |
| Laurie Fowler | 1975-1981 | ||
| Alan Johnson | 1982-1990 | ||
| Darren Cuthbertson | 1992-1993 | #48 in 1991 | |
| David Neitz | 1994-2008 | #38 in 1993 | |
| Jack Trengove | 2010-2017 | ||
| Charlie Spargo | 2018- | ||
No senior games
| Player | Years | Notes | |
| J. Steele | 1931 | ||
| Barry Talochino | 1947 | ||
| R. Nankivell | 1948 | ||
AFLW
Most games: 55 - Libby Birch
Most goals: 10 - Alyssa Mifsud
| Player | Years | Notes | |
| Alyssa Mifsud | 2017 - 2018 | ||
| Libby Birch | 2020 - 2023 | ||
| Georgia Gall | 2024 | Number 27 in 2023 | |
No senior games
| Player | Years | Notes | |
| Talia Radan | 2019 | ||