| VFL/AFL | AFLW | |
VFL/AFL
Most games: 226 - Garry Lyon
Most goals: 426 - Garry Lyon
| Player | Years | Notes |
| Alf George | 1912 | #14 in 1913, #29 in 1915 |
| Jack Robertson | 1913 | #10 in 1912 |
| Jack Huntington | 1914 | #28 in 1915, #19 from 1919 to 1920 |
| Jack McKenzie | 1915 | |
| Percy Love | 1919 | |
| Leo Little | 1920 | #31 in 1919 |
| Ted Thomas | 1921-1929 | #12 in 1932 |
| George Margitich | 1930-1934 | |
| Ken Feltscheer | 1935 | #22 in 1936 |
| John Lewis | 1936-1938 | |
| Bill Baxter | 1939-1941 | |
| Bob Spargo | 1942 | |
| Keith Molloy | 1943 | #27 in 1945 |
| Ron Irwin | 1943-1947 | |
| Geoff Collins | 1948-1952 | #8 in 1954 |
| Peter Marquis | 1953-1958 | |
| Maurie Bartlett | 1964-1966 | |
| Sid Catlin | 1966-1968 | |
| Trevor Rollinson | 1969-1973 | |
| Barry Tippett | 1976-1978 | |
| Henry Coles | 1979-1980 | #13 from 1975 to 1978 |
| Gerard Healy | 1982-85 | #39 from 1979 to 1981 |
| Garry Lyon | 1986-1989 | |
| Clint Bizzell | 2002-2007 | |
| Clint Bartram | 2008-2012 | #19 from 2006 to 2007 |
| Christian Salem | 2014- |
No senior games
| Player | Years | Notes |
| Ron Stephens | 1959 | |
| Tony Bourke | 1960-1963 |
AFLW
Most games: Maddie Gay - 47
Most goals: Maddie Gay - 12
| Player | Years | Notes |
| Emma Humphries | 2017 - 2018 | |
| Maddie Gay | 2019 - 2023 | |
| Alyssia Pisano | 2024- - | |