| VFL/AFL | AFLW | |
VFL/AFL
Most games: 171 - Bryan Kenneally
Most goals: 106 - Harry Moyes
| Player | Years | Notes |
| Bernie Nolan | 1912 | |
| Laurie Brady | 1913 | |
| Carlyle Kenley | 1913 | #1 in 1914 |
| Alec Gray | 1914 | #14 from 1915-1921 |
| Rupe Lowell | 1915 | #6 in 1914 |
| Bill Brunier | 1919 | #38 in 1914, #21 in 1915 |
| Syd Hutcheson | 1920 | |
| Harry Bruce | 1921 | |
| John Corby | 1922 | |
| Jim Makin | 1923 | |
| Harry Moyes | 1925-1927 | |
| Clem Carr | 1928 | #19 in 1929 |
| Ossie Green | 1929 | #5 in 1926 |
| Francis Vine | 1930 | #23 from 1926 to 1934 |
| Reg Conole | 1930-1932 | #29 in 1933 |
| Billy Libbis | 1933-1935 | |
| Ken Feltscheer | 1936 | |
| Harry Harley | 1938-1939 | |
| Shane McGrath | 1940-1941, 1946-1950 | |
| Arthur Franklin | 1942 | |
| Tom Ferguson | 1943 | #16 in 1942 |
| Tony Bizzaca | 1944 | |
| Roy Stabb | 1945 | #8 from 1946 to 1947 |
| Ernie O'Rourke | 1945 | #27 from 1946 to 1948 |
| John Ferguson | 1951-1954 | |
| Ivan Baumgartner | 1955 | |
| Ben Crameri | 1957 | |
| John Kerr | 1958 | |
| Bryan Kenneally | 1959-1969 | |
| Ray Carr | 1970-1972 | |
| Henry Ritterman | 1973 | #45 from 1971-1972 |
| Charles Pagnoccolo | 1974 | |
| Frank Giampaolo | 1975-1977 | #43 from 1973-1974 |
| Ken Whitfort | 1978-1979 | |
| Chris Connolly | 1982-1989 | |
| Stephen Wearne | 1992 | |
| Martin Pike | 1993 | #10 in 1994 |
| Jeff Hilton | 1994-1996 | |
| Shane Woewodin | 1997-2002 | |
| Brent Moloney | 2005-2012 | |
| James Magner | 2013 | #49 in 2012 |
| Viv Michie | 2014-2016 | |
| Aaron vandenBerg | 2017-2021 | |
| Blake Howes | 2024- | Also #22 on list in 2022/2023 |
No senior games
| Player | Years | Notes |
| T. Beamish | 1928 |
AFLW
Most games: 34 - Eliza McNamara
Most goals: 7 - Eliza McNamara
| Player | Years | Notes |
| Maddy Guerin | 2018 | |
| Eliza McNamara | 2021 - 2022 summer, 2023 - |