| VFL/AFL | AFLW | |
VFL/AFL
Most games: 162 - Frank Davis
Most goals: 411 - Fred Fanning
| Player | Years | Notes |
| Bill McKenzie | 1912 | #4 in 1913 and 1919, 27 in 1914, 18 in 1915 |
| Charlie Lilley | 1913 | #11 in 1914, 8 from 1919-1925 |
| Rupe Lowell | 1914 | |
| Herb Matthews | 1919-1922 | |
| Bob Abernethy | 1923 | |
| Johnny Egan | 1924 | |
| Ted Parker | 1925 | |
| Jim Veal | 1926-1927 | |
| Allan Hope | 1928 | |
| Ted Esposito | 1929-1932 | |
| Archie Roberts | 1932-1935 | #27 in 1936 |
| Joe Kinnear | 1936-1937 | #17 in 1932, 15 in 1933, 2 in 1934, 36 in 1935 |
| Jack Harrison | 1936 | |
| Ian Giles | 1939 | |
| Fred Fanning | 1940-1947 | |
| Eddie Craddock | 1948-1950 | #9 in 1947 |
| Kevin Webb | 1951 | |
| Ken Albiston | 1952-1954 | |
| Frank Adams | 1955-1964 | #41 from 1953 to 1954 |
| Frank Davis | 1965-1973 | #40 in 1964 |
| Ross Brewer | 1974-1978 | #27 from 1972-1973 |
| Ken Roberts | 1979 | #10 in 1978 |
| Robert Elliott | 1979-1981 | |
| Michael O'Sullivan | 1982-1986 | |
| Glenn Lovett | 1989-1999 | #51 in 1987 |
| Scott Thompson | 2001-2004 | |
| Matthew Bate | 2006-2012 | |
| Chris Dawes | 2013-2016 | |
| Jordan Lewis | 2017-2019 | |
| Luke Jackson | 2020-2022 | |
| Brodie Grundy | 2023 | |
| Caleb Windsor | 2024- | |
AFLW
Most games: 55 - Daisy Pearce
Most goals: 25 - Daisy Pearce
| Player | Years | Notes |
| Daisy Pearce | 2017 - 2018, 2020 - 2022 spring |
Alyssa Bannan | 2024 - | Number 16 from 2021-2023||