* Denotes active player
VFL/AFL
| Player | MFC debut | Games
|
| Eddie Jackson | Round 3, 1947 | 84
|
| Colin Graham | Round 15, 1975 | 35
|
| Les Bamblett | Round 1, 1983 | 11
|
| Andy Lovell | Round 3, 1988 | 121
|
| Phil Egan | Round 1, 1991 | 1
|
| Fabian Francis | Round 17, 1991 | 1
|
| Sean Charles | Round 10, 1992 | 47
|
| Jeff Farmer | Round 1, 1995 | 118
|
| David Cockatoo-Collins | Round 1, 1996 | 2
|
| Donald Cockatoo-Collins | Round 1, 1996 | 9
|
| Scott Chisholm | Round 1, 1999 | 18
|
| Matthew Whelan | Round 4, 2000 | 150
|
| Aaron Davey | Round 1, 2004 | 178
|
| Shannon Motlop | Round 5, 2005 | 10
|
| Byron Pickett | Round 1, 2006 | 29
|
| Isaac Weetra | Round 1, 2008 | 2
|
| Austin Wonaeamirri | Round 3, 2008 | 31
|
| Jamie Bennell | Round 1, 2009 | 57
|
| Neville Jetta | Round 1, 2009 | 159
|
| Liam Jurrah | Round 12, 2009 | 36
|
| Jay Kennedy Harris | Round 1, 2014 | 39
|
| Dom Barry | Round 15, 2014 | 5
|
| Jeff Garlett | Round 1, 2015 | 78
|
| Steven May | Round 2, 2019 | *
|
| Toby Bedford | Round 1, 2020 | 18
|
| Kysaiah Pickett | Round 1, 2020 | *
|
| Shane McAdam | Round 10, 2024 | * |
AFLW