Nominees (1998 - 2024). Winner in bold.
| Player | Round
|
| Jeff Farmer | Round 11, 1998
|
| Russell Robertson | Round 6, 2001
|
| David Neitz | Round 1, 2002
|
| Russell Robertson | Round 1, 2007
|
| Jamie Bennell | Round 7, 2010
|
| Liam Jurrah | Round 20, 2010
|
| David Rodan | Round 14, 2013
|
| Tom McDonald | Round 14, 2017
|
| Christian Petracca | Round 14, 2020
|
| Kysaiah Pickett | Round 2, 2021
|
| Toby Bedford | Round 15, 2022
|
| Jacob van Rooyen | Round 1A, 2024
|
| Caleb Windsor | Round 3, 2024
|
| Bayley Fritsch | Round 8, 2024 |
AFLW