Nominees (1998 - 2023). Winner in bold.

Player	Round
Jeff Farmer	Round 11, 1998
Russell Robertson	Round 6, 2001
David Neitz	Round 1, 2002
Russell Robertson	Round 1, 2007
Jamie Bennell	Round 7, 2010
Liam Jurrah	Round 20, 2010
David Rodan	Round 14, 2013
Tom McDonald	Round 14, 2017
Christian Petracca	Round 14, 2020
Kysaiah Pickett	Round 2, 2021
Toby Bedford	Round 15, 2022

AFLW

Player	Round
Aliesha Newman	Round 2, 2018
Kate Hore	Round 6, 2020