| VFL/AFL | AFLW | ||
VFL/AFL
Most games: 210 - Gary Hardeman
Most goals: 227 - Jeff Farmer
| Player | Years | Notes | |
| Alf Williamson | 1914 | ||
| Ivor Warne-Smith | 1919 | #14 from 1925 to 1932 | |
| Alex Ogilvy | 1921 | ||
| Edgar Dunbar | 1922-1924 | ||
| Jack Cannan | 1925 | #25 in 1926 | |
| Fred Dick | 1926-1927 | ||
| Geoff Frood | 1930 | ||
| Ron Rutherford | 1932 | ||
| Ray Niven | 1934 | ||
| Frank Halloran | 1935 | ||
| Ted Buckley | 1937-1939 | ||
| Bernie Neenan | 1940-1942 | ||
| Johnny Dalton | 1943 | ||
| Frank McGrath | 1944 | ||
| Warren Lewis | 1944 | #11 in 1941 | |
| Bruce Edge | 1945 | ||
| Ern Rowarth | 1945 | #1 from 1946 to 1947 | |
| Des Bell | 1947-1948 | #36 in 1946 | |
| Alan McGowan | 1948 | #20 from 1949 to 1950 | |
| Jack Thomson | 1949-1953 | ||
| Colin Wilson | 1954-1959 | ||
| Robert Miller | 1961-1965 | ||
| Gary Hardeman | 1967-1977 | #11 in 1981 | |
| Tony May | 1978 | ||
| John Dellamarta | 1979 | ||
| Tony Elshaug | 1980-1983 | #50 in 1979 | |
| Greg Healy | 1984-1993 | ||
| Jeff Farmer | 1995-2001 | #8 also in 1999 | |
| Cameron Hunter | 2003-2005 | ||
| Byron Pickett | 2006-2007 | ||
| Austin Wonaeamirri | 2010-2011 | #39 in 2008 | |
| Dom Barry | 2014 | ||
| Jake Spencer | 2017 | #42 from 2009 to 2015 | |
| Oskar Baker | 2019-2021 | ||
| Tom Fullarton | 2025 | Also on list in 2024 | |
| Latrelle Pickett | 2026- | ||
No senior games
| Player | Years | Notes | |
| Rod Meldrum | 1966 | ||
AFLW
Most games: 14 - Lily Johnson
Most goals: 3 - Sarah Perkins
| Player | Years | Notes | |
| Sarah Perkins | 2020 | ||
| Lily Johnson | 2024 - 2025 | ||
No senior games
| Player | Years | Notes | |
| Jordan Zanchetta | 2022 summer | ||
| Ella Little | 2022 spring | ||