Most games: 154 - Brian Wilson
Most goals: 208 - Brian Wilson
| Player | Years | Notes |
| Bill Hickey | 1912 | |
| Norm McDougall | 1913 | |
| Jack Evans | 1914 | Number 29 in 1912, 8 in 1913 and 1915, 28 in 1919 |
| Harry Brereton | 1915 | Number 2 in 1912 |
| Reg Gibb | 1919 | Number 19 in 1915 |
| Bill Hore | 1919 | |
| Mick Anthony | 1920-1924 | |
| Frank Jorgensen | 1925-1927 | |
| Norman Driver | 1928-1930 | |
| Bert Avery | 1931-1933 | |
| Bert Taylor | 1934-1936 | |
| Hugh Murnane | 1937-1940 | |
| Jack Heal | 1942 | |
| Bob Stone | 1943 | Number 32 in 1942, 36 in 1949 |
| Clem Conroy | 1944-1946 | |
| Eddie Jackson | 1947-1952 | |
| Geoff Case | 1953-1962 | |
| Owen Zinko | 1963-1964 | |
| Graham Osborne | 1966-1975 | Number 24 from 1976 to 1977 |
| Ray Smith | 1976 | Number 43 in 1975 |
| Barry Denny | 1977-1979 | |
| Phil Pinnell | 1980-1981 | |
| Brian Wilson | 1982-1990 | |
| Rod Owen | 1991 | |
| Darren Kowal | 1992-1999 | |
| Stephen Powell | 2000-2002 | |
| Gary Moorcroft | 2003 | |
| Brad Miller | 2004-2010 | Number 37 from 2002 to 2003 |
| Jamie Bennell | 2011-2012 | Number 43 from 2009 to 2010 |
| Jack Viney | 2013- |
Players who didn't play a senior match
| Player | Years | Notes |
| L. Josephs | 1942 | |
| Bill Baxter | 1943 | Number 3 from 1939 to 1941 |
| Ian Sheppard | 1965 |