Player	MFC games	MFC goals	Years
Charles Pagnoccolo	1	0	1974
Les Parish	7	5	1985
Roy Park	13	35	1915
Bert Parke	30	0	1907-1910, 1912
Greg Parke	119	169	1968-1973
Ted Parker	1	0	1925
Harry Parkin	85	0	1900-1906
Eric Parsons	2	0	1914
Laurie Paul	2	2	1899, 1902
Dennis Payne	1	0	1974
Paul Payne	28	5	1985-1988
Rod Payne	13	6	1970
Nevin Paynter	12	0	1950-1951, 1953
George Peacock	35	11	1905-1907
Joe Pearce	152	5	1904-1913
Eric Peck	6	0	1922-1923
Cameron Pedersen	64	50	2013-2018
Edwin Pemberton	36	5	1930-1934
Stan Penberthy	11	0	1937
Ern Penrose	1	0	1905
Nick Pesch	4	0	1997
Ricky Petterd	54	55	2007-2012
Harrison Petty	*	*	2018-
Michael Pickering	15	12	1992-1993
Byron Pickett	29	16	2006-2007
Kysaiah Pickett	*	*	2020-
Jack Pickford	2	0	192
Bruce Pie	1	0	1926
Terry Pierce	3	0	1951-1952
Martin Pike	24	25	1993-1994
Alby Pilcher	1	0	1903
Graeme Pinfold	20	4	1957-1961
Phil Pinnell	28	10	1980-1981
Dick Pirrie	24	11	1898-1900
Steven Pitt	5	2	2000-2001
Ted Politz	26	19	1911-1913
Michael Polley	5	0	1996
Ivan Porter	25	31	1944-1946
Arthur Pound	7	12	1950
Danny Powell	7	6	1942
Daryl Powell	2	0	1969
Stephen Powell	44	43	2000, 2002
Jack Power	36	6	1930-1934
Mike Power	2	0	1974
Archie Pratt	3	0	1910
Braydon Preuss	10	4	2019-2020
Alec Proudfoot	1	0	1929
Paul Prymke	49	2	1994-1996
Bob Puflett	4	0	1902
Hugh Purse	84	26	1904-1909, 1912, 1915
Jack Purse	109	12	1900-1906, 1908
Robert Pyman	19	8	1997