Most games: 108 - Tony Dullard
Most goals: 101 - Adrian Dullard
| Player | Years | Notes |
| Clarrie Abbott | 1912 | |
| Len Incigneri | 1913-1914 | #25 in 1915 |
| Percy Ellingsen | 1913 | |
| Jack Huntington | 1915 | #3 in 1914, #19 from 1919-1920 |
| Matt Connors | 1919 | |
| Bob Bodington | 1919 | |
| Jack Evans | 1919 | #29 in 1912, #8 in 1913 and 1915, #7 in 1914 |
| George Walker | 1920 | #26 in 1914, #20 in 1915 and 1920-1921, #16 in 1919 |
| Alec Farrow | 1921 | #25 in 1919, #4 in 1920 |
| Harold Dunbar | 1922 | |
| Hugh Dunbar | 1923-1928 | #29 in 1922 |
| Henry McCrae | 1929 | |
| Webber Jackson | 1930-1932 | |
| Bill Robinson | 1933 | |
| Pat McNamara | 1934-1938 | |
| Ted Cordner | 1941-1943 | #23 in 1946 |
| Percy Taylor | 1944-1945 | |
| Adrian Dullard | 1946-1949 | #34 from 1940-1943, #18 in 1945 |
| Greg Lourey | 1950 | #17 in 1948 |
| Bill Smeaton | 1951-1952 | |
| Terry Gleeson | 1953-1962 | |
| David Robbie | 1963-1965 | |
| Derek Feldmann | 1967-1970 | |
| Tony Dullard | 1973-1981 | |
| David Cordner | 1982-1987 | |
| Jamie Duursma | 1988-1989 | |
| John Howat | 1990-1992 | #51 in 1989 |
| Glenn Molloy | 1993-1996 | |
| Nick Pesch | 1997 | |
| Matthew Collins | 1998-2001 | |
| Phil Read | 2004-2006 | |
| Isaac Weetra | 2007 | |
| Joel MacDonald | 2010-2013 | |
| Oscar McDonald | 2015-2020 |
Players who never played a senior match
| Player | Years | Notes |
| Harcourt Dowsley | 1940 | |
| Majak Daw | 2021-2022 | |
| Will Verrall | 2023 | |
Notes
Official sources show Les Gibbs wearing number 28 in 1939, but Football Record shows number 27.