Saturday 1 September - Argyle Ground
It was agreed that the match on a paddock near the Argyle Hotel would be played 25-a-side, but while the locals had their full complement of players Melbourne could only muster 20.
The visitors won the toss, kicking with the advantage of a wind and downhill on the sloping ground. In the first game in Geelong played with an oval ball the clubs played for three hours without a score, with Geelong defending stoutly for much of the day. Busevi almost kicked the winning goal but narrowly missed.
Best were Smith, Harrison and Hammersley.
Armitage, Amsinck, Busevi, Baker, Bruce, Byrne, J. Baker, A. Bruce, Cobb, Elliott, Freame, Harrison, Hammersley (c), Hurst, Ireland, Kenworthy, Lightfoot, Morrison, McCrae, Macintosh, Montgomery, May, O'Mullane, Petrie, Shiels, Stypmann, Smith, Shoesmith, JB Thompson, W Thompson, Russell, Wardill, HR Woolley, S Woolley.
Some sources say Melbourne drew on several Richmond players for the match, and that the five player advantage was a deliberate move rather than a result of Melbourne's inability to field a full side.
Geelong Advertiser - 01/09/1860
Argus - 03/09/1860
Geelong Advertiser - 03/09/1860
Age - 04/09/1860
Bell's Life In Victoria - 08/09/1860